 |
These are the messages that have been posted on inthe00s over the past few years.
Check out the messageboard archive index for a complete list of topic areas.
This archive is periodically refreshed with the latest messages from the current messageboard.
This is a topic from the Penguin Ratings forum on inthe00s.
Check for new replies or respond here...
Subject: Rate These Guitarists!
Written By: HawkTheSlayer on 05/19/06 at 8:01 pm
Some people define music or bands by the guitarist they use.
Therefore, ergo and to with, rate these axe-men!
Standard 1-5 ratings, please.
(I know there will be some missing, but remember...this is my rating thread. You may use others in your own, thank you!) ;D
Neal Schon- Journey
K.K. Downing- Judas Priest
Joe Satriani- His Own Band
Bill Spooner- Formerly of The Tubes
Stuart Adamson- Big Country
Marco Pirroni- Adam & The Ants, Sex Pistols
Bob Casale- Devo
Andy Summers- The Police
Ace Frehley- Formerly of KISS, Frehley's Comet
Pete Townshend- The Who
Joey Kramer- Aerosmith
Jah Wobble- Formerly of Public Image Ltd. (p.i.l.)
Chris Squire- Yes
David Rhodes- Core Band (Peter Gabriel)
James Young- Styx
Subject: Re: Rate These Guitarists!
Written By: Sister Morphine on 05/20/06 at 1:27 am
Just one thing. No Jimmy Page? WHAT?!
Subject: Re: Rate These Guitarists!
Written By: HawkTheSlayer on 05/20/06 at 4:07 am
Just one thing. No Jimmy Page? WHAT?!
I explained that there would be some missing, but this is my thread. You may use Jimmy Page in your thread, man.
I used the ones I know best. I am sorry, but I am not a big Zep fan. :-X
Subject: Re: Rate These Guitarists!
Written By: micah on 05/20/06 at 4:34 pm
Neal Schon-Journey...3
K.K.Downing--Judas Priest...4
Joe Satriani--3
Bill Spooner--3
Bob Casale--Devo--2
Andy Summers--The Police--5
Ace Frehley--4
Pete Townsend--The Who--5
Joey Kramer--Aerosmith--5
Chris Squire--Yes--5
James Young--Styx-5
Subject: Re: Rate These Guitarists!
Written By: La Roche on 05/20/06 at 4:43 pm
Neal Schon- Journey - 3
K.K. Downing- Judas Priest - 5
Joe Satriani- His Own Band - 5
Marco Pirroni- Adam & The Ants, Sex Pistols - 2
Andy Summers- The Police - 4
Ace Frehley- Formerly of KISS, Frehley's Comet - 4
Pete Townshend- The Who - 5
Joey Kramer- Aerosmith - 5
Jah Wobble- Formerly of Public Image Ltd. (p.i.l.) - 3
Chris Squire- Yes - 2
James Young- Styx - 3.5
Subject: Re: Rate These Guitarists!
Written By: Tia on 05/20/06 at 5:14 pm
point of order? chris squire was actually yes' bass player, no? i'd definitely give steve howe high marks, though, and trevor rabin only slightly less.
Subject: Re: Rate These Guitarists!
Written By: Dominic L. on 05/20/06 at 6:49 pm
Bob Casale-4
Pete Townshend- 4
Subject: Re: Rate These Guitarists!
Written By: HawkTheSlayer on 05/23/06 at 7:09 pm
point of order? chris squire was actually yes' bass player, no? i'd definitely give steve howe high marks, though, and trevor rabin only slightly less.
He was both a guitarist and a bass player.
Steve Howe, Trevor Rabin, and Bill Bruford were primary Yes guitarists.
Subject: Re: Rate These Guitarists!
Written By: Tia on 05/23/06 at 7:31 pm
i thought bill bruford replaced rick wakeman!
wow, i gotta update my flashcards.
Subject: Re: Rate These Guitarists!
Written By: La Roche on 05/23/06 at 8:53 pm
He was both a guitarist and a bass player.
Although not a particularly great one. ;)
Subject: Re: Rate These Guitarists!
Written By: Tia on 05/23/06 at 8:59 pm
i liked chris squire's bass work (for a pick player); i wasn't aware that he played guitar.
i mean most bass players diddle with guitar but i wasn't aware he did it seriously...
Subject: Re: Rate These Guitarists!
Written By: HawkTheSlayer on 05/24/06 at 11:38 am
He was mostly on bass, but yes, he did do guitar work.
Another axe-man ppl have asked about is Brian May.
I chose not to include him, because there are those rare few who need no rating.
Plus...I didn't think of him until after I created the rating roster. :-[