1. Something
2. The Long And Winding Road
3. Yesterday
4. Yellow Submarine
5. Fool On The Hill
6. Do You Want To Know A Secret
7. If I Fell
8. Strawberry Fields Forever
9. I Wanna Hold Your Hand
10. Eight Days A Week
11. Ticket To Ride
12. Birthday
13. We Can Work It Out
14. I Saw Her Standing There
15. Can't Buy Me Love
16. Here Comes The Sun
17. All You Need Is Love
18. Back In The USSR
19. Hey Jude
20. Let It Be
21. Michelle
22. Penny Lane
23. Eleanor Rigby
24. All My Loving
25. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds

Did I miss your favorite?  Do tell!

1. Something 4
2. The Long And Winding Road 5
3. Yesterday 4
4. Yellow Submarine 1
5. Fool On The Hill 2
6. Do You Want To Know A Secret 3
7. If I Fell 3
8. Strawberry Fields Forever 3
9. I Wanna Hold Your Hand 3
10. Eight Days A Week 3
11. Ticket To Ride 3
12. Birthday 5
13. We Can Work It Out 3
14. I Saw Her Standing There 3
15. Can't Buy Me Love 3
16. Here Comes The Sun 5
17. All You Need Is Love 4
18. Back In The USSR 1
19. Hey Jude 4
20. Let It Be 4
21. Michelle 3
22. Penny Lane 5
23. Eleanor Rigby  ???
24. All My Loving 3
25. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds 2

my favorites are the ballads, if you didnt notice  :)

1. Something 5!!!!!
2. The Long And Winding Road 3.5
3. Yesterday 5!!!!
4. Yellow Submarine 3
5. Fool On The Hill 4
6. Do You Want To Know A Secret 2
7. If I Fell 3.75
8. Strawberry Fields Forever 3.75
9. I Wanna Hold Your Hand 0
10. Eight Days A Week 1
11. Ticket To Ride 3.75
12. Birthday 4
13. We Can Work It Out 2.5
14. I Saw Her Standing There 4.75
15. Can't Buy Me Love 1
16. Here Comes The Sun 5!!!!!
17. All You Need Is Love 3.5
18. Back In The USSR 5!!!
19. Hey Jude 4.75
20. Let It Be 5!!
21. Michelle 5!!!!!
22. Penny Lane 3.75
23. Eleanor Rigby 4
24. All My Loving 3.75
25. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds 3.5

1. Something...5
2. The Long And Winding Road...2
3. Yesterday..5
4. Yellow Submarine...3
5. Fool On The Hill...2
6. Do You Want To Know A Secret...1 (not one of my faves)
7. If I Fell...5
8. Strawberry Fields Forever...5
9. I Wanna Hold Your Hand...2
10. Eight Days A Week...2
11. Ticket To Ride...3
12. Birthday...5
13. We Can Work It Out...5
14. I Saw Her Standing There...3
15. Can't Buy Me Love..4
16. Here Comes The Sun...5
17. All You Need Is Love...4
18. Back In The USSR...3
19. Hey Jude...3
20. Let It Be...4
21. Michelle...5
22. Penny Lane...5
23. Eleanor Rigby...5
24. All My Loving...3
25. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds....5


26. Lovely Rita...5
27. She's So Heavy...5
28. Helter Skelter...5
29. Within You, Without You...5
30. Come Together....5

Don't get me started! (Check the avatar!)

Tanya

6. Do You Want To Know A Secret...1 (not one of my faves)
7. If I Fell...5
Tanya


I find this section of your answers interesting, because in my opinion the two songs sound very similar.

I find this section of your answers interesting, because in my opinion the two songs sound very similar.


I can see where some instances in the songs sound familiar, but they are different.

Tanya

I can see where some instances in the songs sound familiar, but they are different.

Tanya


I know.. I was just surprised to see a one and a five.

1. Something 4
2. The Long And Winding Road 5
3. Yesterday 5
4. Yellow Submarine 3
5. Fool On The Hill 3
6. Do You Want To Know A Secret 2
7. If I Fell 2
8. Strawberry Fields Forever 4
9. I Wanna Hold Your Hand 2
10. Eight Days A Week 3
11. Ticket To Ride 2
12. Birthday 1
13. We Can Work It Out 3
14. I Saw Her Standing There 2
15. Can't Buy Me Love 2
16. Here Comes The Sun 5
17. All You Need Is Love 3
18. Back In The USSR 3
19. Hey Jude 3
20. Let It Be 5
21. Michelle 4
22. Penny Lane 3
23. Eleanor Rigby 5
24. All My Loving 3
25. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds 2

Did I miss your favorite?  Do tell!

Others:
My Guitar Gently Weeps 5
Come Together 5
Across the Universe 5
Blackbird 4
I want you (She's so Heavy) 5 music 1 lyrics
Day in the Life 5
Sgt. Pepper/Little help From my Friends 5
She Leaving Home 4


Like Tanya, I could go on and on and on... ;)




Cat

Every song on the list gets a 5 from me. So does most every song not on the list.

1. Something 5+
2. The Long And Winding Road 3.5 original version, 4 "naked"
3. Yesterday 4
4. Yellow Submarine 4
5. Fool On The Hill 2
6. Do You Want To Know A Secret 5
7. If I Fell 4
8. Strawberry Fields Forever5+
9. I Wanna Hold Your Hand 4.5
10. Eight Days A Week 4
11. Ticket To Ride 4
12. Birthday 4
13. We Can Work It Out 5
14. I Saw Her Standing There 5+
15. Can't Buy Me Love 4
16. Here Comes The Sun 5
17. All You Need Is Love 4.5
18. Back In The USSR 4
19. Hey Jude 5
20. Let It Be 5
21. Michelle 5+ (Probably my fave on this list)
22. Penny Lane 4.5
23. Eleanor Rigby 5
24. All My Loving 3
25. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds 5

Did I miss your favorite?  Do tell!

My favorite is probably "I'm Looking Through You." I can't get enough of it! Other favorites of mine that you didn't mention:
-Oh! Darling
-Golden Slumbers, Polethene Pam, Carry That Weight, hell, the entire Abbey Roud Suite except for Mean Mr. Mustard
-Helter Skelter
-The Continuing Story of Bungalow Bill
-Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band/A Little Help from my Friends
-Come Together
-The Ballad of John and Yoko
-She Said, She Said
-And Your Bird Can Sing
-Baby You're A Rich Man

and so on and so forth  ;D

Rate them all 5!!!

1. Something
2. The Long And Winding Road
3. Yesterday
4. Yellow Submarine
5. Fool On The Hill
6. Do You Want To Know A Secret
7. If I Fell
8. Strawberry Fields Forever
9. I Wanna Hold Your Hand
10. Eight Days A Week
11. Ticket To Ride
12. Birthday
13. We Can Work It Out
14. I Saw Her Standing There
15. Can't Buy Me Love
16. Here Comes The Sun
17. All You Need Is Love
18. Back In The USSR
19. Hey Jude
20. Let It Be
21. Michelle
22. Penny Lane
23. Eleanor Rigby
24. All My Loving
25. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds

Did I miss your favorite?  Do tell!



To narrow it down give all (that is all) the Beatles tracks/songs as 4.

1. Something d/k
2. The Long And Winding Road 4
3. Yesterday 4
4. Yellow Submarine 4.5
5. Fool On The Hill d/k
6. Do You Want To Know A Secret 5
7. If I Fell 5
8. Strawberry Fields Forever 3.5
9. I Want To Hold Your Hand 5
10. Eight Days A Week 4.5
11. Ticket To Ride 4.5
12. Birthday 5
13. We Can Work It Out 5
14. I Saw Her Standing There 5
15. Can't Buy Me Love 4.5
16. Here Comes The Sun 5
17. All You Need Is Love d/k
18. Back In The USSR d/k
19. Hey Jude 3
20. Let It Be 4.5
21. Michelle d/k
22. Penny Lane 4.5
23. Eleanor Rigby 4
24. All My Loving 5
25. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds 5
Write ins:
26. Baby You're A Rich Man 4.5
27. Drive My Car 5
28. Free As A Bird (1995) 4.5
29. Got To Get You Into My Life 4
30. Help 5
31. I Should Have Known Better 5
32. Love Me Do 4.5
33. Ob-La-Di Ob-La-Da 5
34. Paperback Writer 3.5
35. Please Please Me 5
36. P.S. I Love You 4.5
37. Real Love (1996) 4
38. Twist And Shout 5
39. While My Guitar Gently Weeps 4
40. You've Got To Hide Your Love Away 3

Hmm... interesting... Here Comes The Sun is the only one that has gotten a "5" from everyone who has participated... except for Philip Eno, who gave them all a generic "4".  :)

Okay, this is what I'm giving

1. Something --- 2
2. The Long And Winding Road --- 3
3. Yesterday --- 2
4. Yellow Submarine --- 1
5. Fool On The Hill --- 3
6. Do You Want To Know A Secret --- 5
7. If I Fell --- 3
8. Strawberry Fields Forever --- 2
9. I Wanna Hold Your Hand --- 1
10. Eight Days A Week --- 2
11. Ticket To Ride --- 2
12. Birthday --- 2
13. We Can Work It Out --- 3
14. I Saw Her Standing There --- 1
15. Can't Buy Me Love --- 3
16. Here Comes The Sun --- 3
17. All You Need Is Love --- 1
18. Back In The USSR --- 3
19. Hey Jude --- 2
20. Let It Be --- 5
21. Michelle --- 3
22. Penny Lane --- 4
23. Eleanor Rigby --- 5
24. All My Loving --- 2
25. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds --- 1


And for some forgotten ones...

Things We Said Today --- 5
In My Life --- 5
Paperback Writer --- 5
With a Little Help from My Friends --- 4
Two Of Us --- 5

1. Something 4
2. The Long And Winding Road 5
3. Yesterday 5
4. Yellow Submarine 5
5. Fool On The Hill 5
6. Do You Want To Know A Secret 4
7. If I Fell 5
8. Strawberry Fields Forever 5
9. I Wanna Hold Your Hand 4
10. Eight Days A Week 4
11. Ticket To Ride 5
12. Birthday 4
13. We Can Work It Out 4
14. I Saw Her Standing There 4
15. Can't Buy Me Love 5
16. Here Comes The Sun 5
17. All You Need Is Love 5
18. Back In The USSR 5
19. Hey Jude 5
20. Let It Be 5
21. Michelle 4
22. Penny Lane 555555555
23. Eleanor Rigby 5
24. All My Loving 5
25. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds 5

What did you expect??!! :D

I cant believe you guys forgot to mention my favorite Beatles song, 'Get Back'.

Rate them all 5!!!


Now here is a man who knows his music  ;) scale of 1 to 5 give them all a 6

I cant believe you guys forgot to mention my favorite Beatles song, 'Get Back'.
I give 4 to Get Back.

1. Something      3.5
2. The Long And Winding Road      4
3. Yesterday      4
4. Yellow Submarine      3
5. Fool On The Hill      4
6. Do You Want To Know A Secret      4.5
7. If I Fell      5
8. Strawberry Fields Forever      4
9. I Wanna Hold Your Hand      3.5
10. Eight Days A Week      4
11. Ticket To Ride      4.5
12. Birthday      4
13. We Can Work It Out      4
14. I Saw Her Standing There      3.5
15. Can't Buy Me Love      3.5
16. Here Comes The Sun      3
17. All You Need Is Love      3.5
18. Back In The USSR      4.5
19. Hey Jude      4.5
20. Let It Be      4.5
21. Michelle      4
22. Penny Lane      4
23. Eleanor Rigby      5
24. All My Loving      4.5
25. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds      4

Did I miss your favorite?  Do tell!

Yes !  "In My Life" - 5  :)

1. Something-------------0
2. The Long And Winding Road----------------0
3. Yesterday-----------------1
4. Yellow Submarine----------------2
5. Fool On The Hill---------------------0
6. Do You Want To Know A Secret-----------------0000000
7. If I Fell---------------------------0
8. Strawberry Fields Forever----------------1
9. I Wanna Hold Your Hand---------------------------000000000
10. Eight Days A Week---------------------1
11. Ticket To Ride---------------------1
12. Birthday-------------------3
13. We Can Work It Out-----------------0000000
14. I Saw Her Standing There------------------0
15. Can't Buy Me Love------------------00
16. Here Comes The Sun------------------000
17. All You Need Is Love--------------------------0000
18. Back In The USSR-----------------------2
19. Hey Jude--------------------3
20. Let It Be----------------2
21. Michelle-----------------4
22. Penny Lane-------------------------0
23. Eleanor Rigby-------------------3
24. All My Loving------------------------0
25. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds----------------------1

Another forgotten one

She Loves You  -- 5 (yeah, yeah, yeah. a good early one from them)

1. Something-DK
2. The Long And Winding Road-1
3. Yesterday-3
4. Yellow Submarine-1
5. Fool On The Hill-DK
6. Do You Want To Know A Secret-3
7. If I Fell-2
8. Strawberry Fields Forever-1
9. I Wanna Hold Your Hand-1
10. Eight Days A Week-5
11. Ticket To Ride-3
12. Birthday-DK
13. We Can Work It Out-3
14. I Saw Her Standing There-1
15. Can't Buy Me Love-1
16. Here Comes The Sun-1
17. All You Need Is Love-1
18. Back In The USSR-DK
19. Hey Jude-3
20. Let It Be-2
21. Michelle-1
22. Penny Lane-1
23. Eleanor Rigby-1
24. All My Loving-1
25. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds-1

gee, guess I don't like them all that much....tho' Eleanor Rigby made an appearance on my site and some of above I enjoy listening to now & then

1. Something-5
2. The Long And Winding Road-3
3. Yesterday-4
4. Yellow Submarine-3
5. Fool On The Hill-5
8. Strawberry Fields Forever-5
9. I Wanna Hold Your Hand-4
10. Eight Days A Week-4
11. Ticket To Ride-5
12. Birthday-4
13. We Can Work It Out-5
14. I Saw Her Standing There-4
15. Can't Buy Me Love-4
16. Here Comes The Sun-5
17. All You Need Is Love-4
18. Back In The USSR-5
19. Hey Jude-5
20. Let It Be-5
21. Michelle-4
22. Penny Lane-5
23. Eleanor Rigby-5
24. All My Loving-5
25. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds-5


You did miss my favorites!

Real Love, I Am The Walrus, and Revolution 9

OK- 5 is best. but this is hard cuz what I like may not be the most musically accomplished tune...

1. Something really a 4 but I feel a 3.
2. The Long And Winding Road really a 5 I feel a 3
3. Yesterday really a 5
4. Yellow Submarine really a 3. i hate this song.
5. Fool On The Hill  I looove this song! 5 from me, and really a 4
6. Do You Want To Know A Secret  I give it a 4. I'ts a 4.
7. If I Fell  I love this. 4 and 4.
8. Strawberry Fields Forever  I hate this song. but it's really a 4
9. I Wanna Hold Your Hand  eh. 4 for real and a 3 from me
10. Eight Days A Week ditto
11. Ticket To Ride ditto
12. Birthday 3 and 3
13. We Can Work It Out  4 and 4
14. I Saw Her Standing There  3 from me, 4 in real life
15. Can't Buy Me Love ditto
16. Here Comes The Sun  2 from me (eh) but it's a 3
17. All You Need Is Love  2 from me...it's a 4
18. Back In The USSR ditto
19. Hey Jude 4
20. Let It Be 5 but I'm sick of it.
21. Michelle  great. but again, sick of it. 4
22. Penny Lane 4 and 4
23. Eleanor Rigby 4 and 4
24. All My Loving good one. 4 and 4
25. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds  duh. 2 from me but it's great in the music world...4

So many I can't take cuz I've heard them for 40 years and I can't take it anymore.  I like Revovler best now...though I used to love their very first songs in my teen years..  Still, my favorite might be "Girl"

3. Yesterday 10
4. Yellow Submarine 7
9. I Wanna Hold Your Hand 8
10. Eight Days A Week 7
11. Ticket To Ride 7
14. I Saw Her Standing There 6
15. Can't Buy Me Love 8
17. All You Need Is Love 9
19. Hey Jude 9
20. Let It Be 10
21. Michelle 9
25. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds 8

1. Something 5
2. The Long And Winding Road 3
3. Yesterday 4
4. Yellow Submarine 1
8. Strawberry Fields Forever 3
9. I Wanna Hold Your Hand 3
10. Eight Days A Week 3
11. Ticket To Ride 3
12. Birthday 2
13. We Can Work It Out 3
14. I Saw Her Standing There 4
15. Can't Buy Me Love 3
16. Here Comes The Sun 3
17. All You Need Is Love 2
18. Back In The USSR 5
19. Hey Jude 4
20. Let It Be 4
21. Michelle 5
22. Penny Lane 2
23. Eleanor Rigby 4
24. All My Loving 4
25. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds 1

1. Something - 9.6
2. The Long And Winding Road - 8.7
3. Yesterday - 6.9 (massively overrated)
4. Yellow Submarine - 7.3
5. Strawberry Fields Forever - 7.7 (also overrated)
6. I Wanna Hold Your Hand - 8.1
7. Fool On The Hill - 9.1 (massively underrated)
8. Eight Days A Week - 5.9
9. Ticket To Ride - 8.0
10. Birthday - 4.8
11. We Can Work It Out - 8.5
12. I Saw Her Standing There - 8.8
13. Can't Buy Me Love - 9.0
14. Here Comes The Sun - 9.3
15. All You Need Is Love - 7.3
16. Back In The USSR - 6.2
17. Hey Jude - 8.7
18. Let It Be - 8.8
19. Michelle - 7.0 (hugely overrated)
20. Penny Lane - 9.0
21. Eleanor Rigby - 9.0
22. All My Loving - 4.2
23. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds (don't like it at all) - 5.1


MY TOP 5.

1. Something  9.6
2. Tommorow Never Knows  9.5
3. While My Guitar Gently Weeps  9.5
4. Here Comes The Sun  9.3
5. Penny Lane 9.1
6. Nowhere Man  9.1
7. Fool On The Hill  9.0
8. Julia  9.0
9. A Day In The Life  8.9
10. I Should've Known Better  8.9