A Hazy Shade of Winter
America
A Most Peculiar Man
April Come She Will
At the Zoo
Baby Driver
Bleeker Street
Blessed
Bridge Over Troubled Waters
Bye Bye Love
Cecilia
Cloudy
El Condor Pasa (If I Could)
Fakin' It
For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her)
Go Tell It On the Mountain
He Was My Brother
Homeward Bound
I Am a Rock
Kathy's Song
Keep the Customer Satisfied
Last Night I Had the Strangest Dream
Leaves That Are Green
Mrs. Robinson
Old Friends/Bookends Theme
Overs
Patterns
Peggy-O
Richard Cory
Save the Life Of My Child
Scarborough Fair
So Long, Frank Lloyd Wright
Somewhere They Can't Find Me
Song For the Asking
Sound of Silence
Sparrow
The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine
The Dangling Conversation
The Only Living Boy In New York
The Times They Are A-Changin'
The 59th Bridge Street Song (Feelin' Groovy)
Voices of Old People
Wednesday Morning 3 AM
We've Got a Groovy Thing Goin'
Why Don't You Write Me
You Can Tell the World
7 O'Clock News/Silent Night

Bridge Over Troubled Waters  5+
Cecilia  3.5
El Condor Pasa (If I Could)  4
Homeward Bound  3.5
I Am a Rock  4
Mrs. Robinson  4
Scarborough Fair  4.5
Sound of Silence  5+
The 59th Bridge Street Song (Feelin' Groovy)  3.5

I don't see "The Boxer" listed...?  I would rate that one a 5!  :D

Oh my gosh, I can't believe I forgot "The Boxer"!!!

Add The Boxer

A Hazy Shade of Winter           3...I like the Bangles' remake better
America                         4
Bridge Over Troubled Waters       3
Bye Bye Love                       4
Cecilia                                 5 this is fun to sing :)
El Condor Pasa (If I Could)       5...this makes me feel good :)For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her)      2
He Was My Brother                        3
Homeward Bound                          4
I Am a Rock                              5...my defense song :)
Mrs. Robinson                            5
Scarborough Fair                        3
Sound of Silence                        4
The 59th Bridge Street Song (Feelin' Groovy)       5

A Hazy Shade of Winter ... 3
America ... 5
April Come She Will ... 4
Bridge Over Troubled Waters ... 5
Bye Bye Love ... 3.5
Cecilia ... 4
El Condor Pasa (If I Could) ... 4
Go Tell It On the Mountain ... 3
Homeward Bound ... 4
I Am a Rock ... 4
Mrs. Robinson ... 4
Scarborough Fair ... 4
Sound of Silence ... 4
Sparrow ... 3
The Times They Are A-Changin' ... 3.5
The 59th Bridge Street Song (Feelin' Groovy) ... 5
The Boxer ... 4.5

It's easy to see that I'm a fan!  :D  Great songs.

Going to rate my own songs...

A Hazy Shade of Winter----3.5 (like the lyrics)

America----3.75

A Most Peculiar Man---3.25 (not bad but depressing)

April Come She Will----4

At the Zoo---3.25

Baby Driver---2 (one of my least favorites)

Bleeker Street----4.25

Blessed----3.5

Bridge Over Troubled Waters---3.5

Bye Bye Love---2.75

Cecilia---3

Cloudy----3.75 (eerie!)

El Condor Pasa (If I Could)---3.5

Fakin' It----3.5

For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her)----4 (haunting!)

Go Tell It On the Mountain----3.5

He Was My Brother----3.75 (almost broke into tears listening to it the first few times)

Homeward Bound---3.5

I Am a Rock---3.75 (especially good when I'm in a foul mood)

Kathy's Song---4.5 (sad and beautiful)

Keep the Customer Satisfied---3.75 (good lyrics)

Last Night I Had the Strangest Dream---3.75 (good song to fantasize about)

Leaves That Are Green----4.5

Mrs. Robinson----3.75 (most played S&G song on the radio, but still like it)

Old Friends/Bookends Theme---4.75 (haunting!)

Overs---3.5

Patterns---4.25

Peggy-O----4

Richard Cory---4.5

Save the Life Of My Child----4.25

Scarborough Fair---5 (gets often played on the radio, but I still find it so beautiful)

So Long, Frank Lloyd Wright---3.75

Somewhere They Can't Find Me----1.25 (why did they have to make a sequel to such a beautiful song! Ruins the imagination >:( )

Song For the Asking---3 (neutral. Rather boring)

Sound of Silence----3.5 for the mellow version and 3.75 for the later version

Sparrow----4

The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine----2.25  :P (I think they were trying to hard to sound like Bob Dylan)

The Dangling Conversation----5 (another sad and beautiful song)

The Only Living Boy In New York----3.5

The Times They Are A-Changin'----3.5 (another Bob Dylan imitation but the lyrics are good)

The 59th Bridge Street Song (Feelin' Groovy)---3 (ok)

Voices of Old People----3

Wednesday Morning 3 AM------3.75

We've Got a Groovy Thing Goin'----4.75

Why Don't You Write Me----3.75

You Can Tell the World----3.75

7 O'Clock News/Silent Night----4 (gives me chills how the news gets louder)

A Hazy Shade of Winter 5!!!!!!! amazing song
America 4
A Most Peculiar Man:???
April Come She Will:???
At the Zoo 4
Baby Driver:???
Bleeker Street 3.75
Blessed:???
Bridge Over Troubled Waters 5
Bye Bye Love 3
Cecilia 5!!!!
Cloudy:???
El Condor Pasa (If I Could) 3.75
Fakin' It 4
For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her) 3.5
Go Tell It On the Mountain 3.5
He Was My Brother:???
Homeward Bound 4
I Am a Rock 3.75
Kathy's Song 3
Keep the Customer Satisfied 3.75
Last Night I Had the Strangest Dream:???
Leaves That Are Green:???
Mrs. Robinson 5
Old Friends/Bookends Theme 3.5 boring
Overs 3.5
Patterns 3
Peggy-O:???
Richard Cory:???
Save the Life Of My Child 4
Scarborough Fair 3.75
So Long, Frank Lloyd Wright 3.5
Somewhere They Can't Find Me:???
Song For the Asking:???
Sound of Silence 4
Sparrow:???
The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine:???
The Dangling Conversation:???
The Only Living Boy In New York:???
The Times They Are A-Changin' havent hard their version
The 59th Bridge Street Song (Feelin' Groovy) 3.75
Voices of Old People 0 this isnt a song...
Wednesday Morning 3 AM 3.75
We've Got a Groovy Thing Goin' blanked
Why Don't You Write Me:???
You Can Tell the World:???
7 O'Clock News/Silent Night:???
the boxer 3.75

A Hazy Shade of Winter - ****
America - ***.5
A Most Peculiar Man - ****
April Come She Will - ****.5
At the Zoo - ***
Baby Driver - ****.5
Bleeker Street - ***.5
Blessed - ****
Bridge Over Troubled Waters - *****
Bye Bye Love - ****
Cecilia - **.5
Cloudy - ***.5
El Condor Pasa (If I Could) - *****.5
Fakin' It - **
For Emily, (Whenever I May Find Her) - ***.5
Go Tell It On the Mountain - **
He Was My Brother - **
Homeward Bound - ***.5
I Am a Rock - ***
Kathy's Song - ***.5
Keep the Customer Satisfied - ****
Last Night I Had the Strangest Dream - ***.5
Leaves That Are Green - ****
Mrs. Robinson - **.5
Old Friends/Bookends Theme - **
Overs - **.5
Patterns - ****
Peggy-O - ****
Richard Cory - ****.5
Save the Life Of My Child - *****
Scarborough Fair - *****.5
So Long, Frank Lloyd Wright - ***.5
Somewhere They Can't Find Me - ***
Song For the Asking - ****
Sound of Silence - ****.5
Sparrow - ****
The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine - ****
The Dangling Conversation - ***.5
The Only Living Boy In New York - *****.5
The Times They Are A-Changin' - ***
The 59th Bridge Street Song (Feelin' Groovy) - ***
Voices of Old People - (not really a song now, is it?)**
Wednesday Morning 3 AM - ***.5
We've Got a Groovy Thing Goin' - ***.5
Why Don't You Write Me - ****
You Can Tell the World - **.5
7 O'Clock News/Silent Night - **