1.  The Sad Cafe--The Eagles
2.  Bridge Over Troubled Water--Simon and Garfunkel
3.  Bob--Weird Al Yankovic
4.  Soak Up The Sun--Sheryl Crow
5.  I Believe--Blessid Union of Souls
6.  Eyes Without a Face--Billy Idol
7.  Oh Sheila--Ready For The World
8.  Bigger Than My Body--John Mayer
9.  You Give Love a Bad Name--Bon Jovi
10.  Dangerous--Roxette
11.  My Girl--The Temptations
12.  Bright Lights--Matchbox Twenty
13.  I Am Henry VIII I Am--Herman's Hermits
14.  California Dreaming--The Mamas and the Papas
15.  Downtown--Petula Clark
16.  Your Wildest Dreams--The Moody Blues
17.  Dude Looks Like A Lady--Aerosmith
18.  Drive--R.E.M.
19.  Ms. Jackson--OutKast
20.  Dance With My Father--Luther Vandross
21.  I Missed Again--Phil Collins
22.  Do You Like The Way--Santana feat. Lauryn Hill and Cee-Lo
23.  After Midnight--Eric Clapton
24.  Carnival--Natelie Merchant
25.  Girl I'm Gonna Miss You--Milli Vanilli

1.  The Sad Cafe--The Eagles  Good song!  4
2.  Bridge Over Troubled Water--Simon and Garfunkel  Another good song!  5
4. Soak Up The Sun--Sheryl Crow  Don't care for this one.  2
6.  Eyes Without a Face--Billy Idol  You can't go wrong with Billy!  5
7.  Oh Sheila--Ready For The World  Oh goodness, I forgot to add this one to my list of songs I'd want to KILL!  0   :P
9.  You Give Love a Bad Name--Bon Jovi  3
10.  Dangerous--Roxette  3.5
11.  My Girl--The Temptations  3.5
13.  I Am Henry VIII I Am--Herman's Hermits  LOL!  3
14.  California Dreaming--The Mamas and the Papas  5
15.  Downtown--Petula Clark  Goin' for the oldies now, I see.  3   ;D
16.  Your Wildest Dreams--The Moody Blues  Great song!  4.5
17.  Dude Looks Like A Lady--Aerosmith  I'm not a big Aerosmith fan but I like their earlier material.  I'll give this one a 3.
18.  Drive--R.E.M.  I can't remember how this one goes.  I guess I should pull out my CD and give it a listen!  ;D
21.  I Missed Again--Phil Collins  3.5
23.  After Midnight--Eric Clapton  3.5
24.  Carnival--Natelie Merchant  3.5
25.  Girl I'm Gonna Miss You--Milli Vanilli  3  

2.  Bridge Over Troubled Water--Simon and Garfunkel 4
4.  Soak Up The Sun--Sheryl Crow 2.5
5.  I Believe--Blessid Union of Souls 1.5
8.  Bigger Than My Body--John Mayer 1
9.  You Give Love a Bad Name--Bon Jovi 3
11.  My Girl--The Temptations 3
12.  Bright Lights--Matchbox Twenty 4.5
13.  I Am Henry VIII I Am--Herman's Hermits 3.5
14.  California Dreaming--The Mamas and the Papas 3.5
15.  Downtown--Petula Clark 3
16.  Your Wildest Dreams--The Moody Blues 3.5
17.  Dude Looks Like A Lady--Aerosmith  3
19.  Ms. Jackson--OutKast 1
24.  Carnival--Natelie Merchant 2

2.  Bridge Over Troubled Water--Simon and Garfunkel ... 4
3.  Bob--Weird Al Yankovic ... 3.5
5.  I Believe--Blessid Union of Souls ... is this the "I believe for every drop of rain that falls, a flower grows" one ??
6.  Eyes Without a Face--Billy Idol ... 3
9.  You Give Love a Bad Name--Bon Jovi ... 3.5
10.  Dangerous--Roxette ... 2.5
11.  My Girl--The Temptations ... 4
13.  I Am Henry VIII I Am--Herman's Hermits ... 4 (hehe)
14.  California Dreaming--The Mamas and the Papas ... 5
15.  Downtown--Petula Clark ... 4
16.  Your Wildest Dreams--The Moody Blues ... 4
19.  Ms. Jackson--OutKast ... 3
21.  I Missed Again--Phil Collins ... 3
23.  After Midnight--Eric Clapton ... 3.5
25.  Girl I'm Gonna Miss You--Milli Vanilli ... 3

1. The Sad Cafe - The Eagles 4
2. Bridge Over Troubled Water - Simon & Garfunkel 4, unneccessary 'big' ending...
6. Eyes Without A Face - Billy Idol 4, nice moody effort - one of his better ones...
7. Oh Sheila - Ready For The World 1, plastic-sounding pop-dance thing...all that was bad about the 80's in 4 minutes...!
9. You Give Love A Bad Name - Bon Jovi 4
11. My Girl - Temptations 5, played to death, I know...but still one of the finest soul records ever...
13. I'm Henry VIII I Am - Herman's Hermits 3, extreme novelty value, but they just get away with it...song goes back to the late 19th century music-hall tradition...
14. California Dreaming - Mamas & Papas 5, can't really fault this groups' harmonies...fine song
15. Downtown - Petula Clark 5, her theme tune, and the one that really made her name Stateside...fantastic arrangement and it still sounds great today...
16. Your Wildest Dreams - Moody Blues 4, not their best, but very good...
17. Dude (Looks Like A Lady) - Aerosmith 3, run-of-the-mill stuff, but not terrible...
21. I Missed Again - Phil Collins 3, lots of horns (which I like), but ultimately nothing too special...
23. After Midnight - Eric Clapton 4
25. Girl I'm Gonna Miss You - Milli Vanilli 1, awful piece of slop...

jaytee - I've not heard it myself (hence no rating), but I'm pretty sure that the 'I Believe' up there is a different song to the one you (and I) know...! I'm sure lebiew will put us right...!

1.  The Sad Cafe--The Eagles Nowhere near their best.  2.5
2.  Bridge Over Troubled Water--Simon and Garfunkel 5
3.  Bob--Weird Al Yankovic Only Weird Al could make every line in the song a palindrome, have the whole song rhyme, and sing it all like Bob Dylan.  4.5
4.  Soak Up The Sun--Sheryl Crow Gotten old
5.  I Believe--Blessid Union of Souls Afraid we're not thinking of the same song, jaytee... :-/   3
6.  Eyes Without a Face--Billy Idol 5
7.  Oh Sheila--Ready For The World 2.5
8.  Bigger Than My Body--John Mayer Ladies and gentlemen, another annoying and boring single from John Mayer.  I honestly HATE this song.  1
9.  You Give Love a Bad Name--Bon Jovi 4
10.  Dangerous--Roxette 3
11.  My Girl--The Temptations 4
12.  Bright Lights--Matchbox Twenty They keep gettin' better!  5
13.  I Am Henry VIII I Am--Herman's Hermits OMG this is annoying. 1.5
14.  California Dreaming--The Mamas and the Papas I hate the Mamas and the Papas, and this is probably their best song in my opinion.  2.5
15.  Downtown--Petula Clark 3.5
16.  Your Wildest Dreams--The Moody Blues 5+!!!!
17.  Dude Looks Like A Lady--Aerosmith 5
18.  Drive--R.E.M. 5
19.  Ms. Jackson--OutKast I like this one.  4
20.  Dance With My Father--Luther Vandross Sad and meaningful, but not really my thing.  3
21.  I Missed Again--Phil Collins Ehh... he has better.  3
22.  Do You Like The Way--Santana feat. Lauryn Hill and Cee-Lo Every song off Supernatural is good.  4
23.  After Midnight--Eric Clapton Okay  3.5
24.  Carnival--Natelie Merchant I cannot give an honest opinion on this song seeing as how I think all of Natelie Merchant's songs sound the same.  They all get around a 2 though
25.  Girl I'm Gonna Miss You--Milli Vanilli 2.5

2.  Bridge Over Troubled Water--Simon and Garfunkel    4
4.  Soak Up The Sun--Sheryl Crow        3
5.  I Believe--Blessid Union of Souls        5
7.  Oh Sheila--Ready For The World         2
9.  You Give Love a Bad Name--Bon Jovi     5
11.  My Girl--The Temptations         3
12.  Bright Lights--Matchbox Twenty      4
14.  California Dreaming--The Mamas and the Papas       5
15.  Downtown--Petula Clark         3
17.  Dude Looks Like A Lady--Aerosmith      5
19.  Ms. Jackson--OutKast        4
24.  Carnival--Natelie Merchant     4

1.  The Sad Cafe--The Eagles........4
2.  Bridge Over Troubled Water--Simon and Garfunkel.....5+
6.  Eyes Without a Face--Billy Idol.........5....love it !
9.  You Give Love a Bad Name--Bon Jovi..........2
11.  My Girl--The Temptations.........5
13.  I Am Henry VIII I Am--Herman's Hermits.........1
14.  California Dreaming--The Mamas and the Papas........5....I love harmonies !
15.  Downtown--Petula Clark.........4
16.  Your Wildest Dreams--The Moody Blues..........3
17.  Dude Looks Like A Lady--Aerosmith............5 8)
18.  Drive--R.E.M........4
21.  I Missed Again--Phil Collins........4
23.  After Midnight--Eric Clapton..........4
25.  Girl I'm Gonna Miss You--Milli Vanilli..........2

Good one ! ;)

3.  Bob--Weird Al Yankovic 3.5 - not my favorite, but some excellent songwriting here!
4.  Soak Up The Sun--Sheryl Crow 2.5 - catchy
5.  I Believe--Blessid Union of Souls I know this song, but haven't heard it in so long so I can't really give it a rating
8.  Bigger Than My Body--John Mayer 4 - suprisingly good
9.  You Give Love a Bad Name--Bon Jovi 4
11.  My Girl--The Temptations 5
12.  Bright Lights--Matchbox Twenty 4.5
13.  I Am Henry VIII I Am--Herman's Hermits 3 - my world history teacher was just talking about this song the other day and how it's the worst song in the world...
17.  Dude Looks Like A Lady--Aerosmith 2 - okay song
19.  Ms. Jackson--OutKast 5 - great hip-hop song
24.  Carnival--Natelie Merchant Haven't heard this song in so long...

*edited for correction

1.  The Sad Cafe--The Eagles  weve talked about me not remembering this one before
2.  Bridge Over Troubled Water--Simon and Garfunkel  5
3.  Bob--Weird Al Yankovic  4  ah, Weird Al conceptial greatness
4.  Soak Up The Sun--Sheryl Crow  3  I dotn know, theres one line in this song that I like and thats it
5.  I Believe--Blessid Union of Souls:???
6.  Eyes Without a Face--Billy Idol  3  you can go wrong with Billy....but not very often
7.  Oh Sheila--Ready For The World:???
8.  Bigger Than My Body--John Mayer  3  I dont think its that great
9.  You Give Love a Bad Name--Bon Jovi  4
10.  Dangerous--Roxette:???
11.  My Girl--The Temptations 5
12.  Bright Lights--Matchbox Twenty 4 excellent!  I feel that this is the best song Ive heard form them in sme time..or at least since Mad Season
13.  I Am Henry VIII I Am--Herman's Hermits 3.75
14.  California Dreaming--The Mamas and the Papas 3.75
15.  Downtown--Petula Clark 3.5
16.  Your Wildest Dreams--The Moody Blues  4
17.  Dude Looks Like A Lady--Aerosmith 3.75
18.  Drive--R.E.M.  I always forget how this one goes
19.  Ms. Jackson--OutKast  3.5 anyone heard the Vines cover?  its freakin Amazing!
20.  Dance With My Father--Luther Vandross:???
21.  I Missed Again--Phil Collins:????
22.  Do You Like The Way--Santana feat. Lauryn Hill and Cee-Lo:????  
23.  After Midnight--Eric Clapton  5
24.  Carnival--Natelie Merchant:???
25.  Girl I'm Gonna Miss You--Milli Vanilli hahahahahaahahahahaahahahaahahahahaha

1.  The Sad Cafe--The Eagles-Not familiar with it.
2.  Bridge Over Troubled Water--Simon and Garfunkel-3
3.  Bob-Weird Al Yankovic-Never heard it
4.  Soak Up The Sun--Sheryl Crow-1
5.  I Believe--Blessid Union of Souls-2
6.  Eyes Without a Face--Billy Idol-5
7.  Oh Sheila--Ready For The World-2
8.  Bigger Than My Body--John Mayer-Not familiar with it.
9.  You Give Love a Bad Name--Bon Jovi-2.75
10.  Dangerous--Roxette-Not familiar
11.  My Girl--The Temptations-4.75
12.  Bright Lights--Matchbox Twenty-Don't like Matchbox 20
13.  I Am Henry VIII I Am--Herman's Hermits-3
14.  California Dreaming--The Mamas and the Papas-4
15.  Downtown--Petula Clark-3
16.  Your Wildest Dreams--The Moody Blues-4
17.  Dude Looks Like A Lady--Aerosmith-5
18.  Drive--R.E.M.-5
19.  Ms. Jackson--OutKast-3
20.  Dance With My Father--Luther Vandross-3
21.  I Missed Again--Phil Collins-2
22.  Do You Like The Way--Santana feat. Lauryn Hill and Cee-Lo-Again, not familiar with it.
23.  After Midnight--Eric Clapton-5 (The original studio version only)
24.  Carnival--Natelie Merchant-2
25.  Girl I'm Gonna Miss You--Milli Vanilli-3