Sorry Junior, I had to steal your idea. ;D  Here's my CD collection for you to rate:

Beach Boys—The Very Best Of: Sounds Of Summer
Beatles—1
Beatles—Rubber Soul
Beatles—Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band
Billy Joel—Glass Houses
Billy Joel—River of Dreams
Billy Joel—The Stranger
Bruce Springsteen—Greatest Hits
Bruce Springsteen—The Rising
Bryan Adams—So Far So Good
Chicago—Greatest Hits (Chicago IX)
Chicago—Greatest Hits 1982-1989
Dave Matthews Band—Under the Table and Dreaming
Eagles—Greatest Hits Volume II
Eagles—Their Greatest Hits 1971-1975
Elton John—Captain Fantastic and the Brown Dirt Cowboy
Elton John—Greatest Hits
Elton John—Reg Strikes Back
Fleetwood Mac—The Dance
Genesis—Turn It On Again: The Hits
George Michael—Faith
Incubus—Make Yourself
INXS—Kick
John Cougar Mellencamp—American Fool
Live—Throwing Copper
Lynyrd Skynyrd—What’s Your Name
Matchbox Twenty—More Than You Think You Are
Matchbox Twenty—Yourself or Something Like You
Police—Every Breath You Take: The Classics
Police—Synchronicity
REO Speedwagon—The Hits
Santana—Amigos
Santana—Borboletta
Santana—Shaman
Santana—Shango
Santana—Supernatural
Santana—Zebop!
Simon and Garfunkel—Bridge Over Troubled Water
Simon and Garfunkel—Parsley, Sage, Rosemary, and Thyme
Smash Mouth—Astro Lounge
Spin Doctors—Here Comes The Bride
Spin Doctors—Pocket Full of Kryptonite
Spin Doctors—Turn It Upside Down
Styx—Greatest Hits
Sugar Ray—14:59
Sugar Ray—Floored
Wallflowers—Red Letter Days
Weird Al Yankovic—Poodle Hat

Police-Every breath you take: The classics...3.5
Eagles-greatist hits volume II...4
Other Eagles one...4
Santana: Shaman...4.5
Santana: Supernatural...3.5
Weird Al PH...4
REO Speedwagon...3.5


Great list Lebeiw!  ;) Too bad I don't have time the rate them all.

I'm only going to rate the ones that I also have...


Bryan Adams—So Far So Good  5
Chicago—Greatest Hits (Chicago IX)  5
Chicago—Greatest Hits 1982-1989  4.5
Eagles—Greatest Hits Volume II  5+
Eagles—Their Greatest Hits 1971-1975  5+
Elton John—Greatest Hits  5
Police—Every Breath You Take: The Classics  4
REO Speedwagon—The Hits  5
 

Beatles—1 5
Beatles—Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band 5
Matchbox Twenty—More Than You Think You Are 3.5 to 4
Weird Al Yankovic—Poodle Hat 3.5 - the previous two albums are better (Bad Hair Day and Running With Scissors)

rating only the ones where i've heard the entire album...

Smash Mouth—Astro Lounge 5...maybe because of the memories.
Sugar Ray—14:59 4...pretty good, but not as good as
Sugar Ray—Floored, which gets a 4.5.

Beach Boys—The Very Best Of: Sounds Of Summer 3
Beatles—1 4.5
Beatles—Rubber Soul 4
Beatles—Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band 4
Billy Joel—River of Dreams 4.5
Billy Joel—The Stranger 5
Bruce Springsteen—Greatest Hits 5
Bruce Springsteen—The Rising 5
Elton John—Captain Fantastic and the Brown Dirt Cowboy 4
Elton John—Greatest Hits 4
Elton John—Reg Strikes Back 3; not one of his best albums
Fleetwood Mac—The Dance 3.5
Matchbox Twenty—More Than You Think You Are 4
Matchbox Twenty—Yourself or Something Like You 2.5
Santana—Shaman 4
Santana—Supernatural 3
Simon and Garfunkel—Bridge Over Troubled Water 3.5
Simon and Garfunkel—Parsley, Sage, Rosemary, and Thyme 3.5
Styx—Greatest Hits 1.5
Wallflowers—Red Letter Days 5!  everyone should check this one out!
Weird Al Yankovic—Poodle Hat I think this was on someone else's list, but I don't remember what rating I gave it...so, I guess I'll give it a 2.5 this time :)