 |
These are the messages that have been posted on inthe00s over the past few years.
Check out the messageboard archive index for a complete list of topic areas.
This archive is periodically refreshed with the latest messages from the current messageboard.
This is a topic from the The 2000's forum on inthe00s.
Check for new replies or respond here...
Subject: Who should judge "American Idol" if Paula Abdul was to leave...
Written By: woops on 03/01/05 at 3:32 pm
:D
Though that one episode with Gibson singing "Lost In Your Eyes" with the finalists was the only episode I saw & was worth watching.
Disclaimer: Paula Abdul is still the judge. This is just a fantast poll :)
Subject: Re: Who should judge "American Idol" if Paula Abdul was to leave...
Written By: Leo Jay on 03/01/05 at 3:35 pm
Ben Stein would make a fabulous judge.
Subject: Re: Who should judge "American Idol" if Paula Abdul was to leave...
Written By: Alchoholica on 03/01/05 at 3:35 pm
Me, i have more talent than all of them combined  :P
Subject: Re: Who should judge "American Idol" if Paula Abdul was to leave...
Written By: EthanM on 03/01/05 at 3:39 pm
Ben Stein would make a fabulous judge.
I think Lewis Black might be a little better... for entertainment value at least.
Subject: Re: Who should judge "American Idol" if Paula Abdul was to leave...
Written By: Leo Jay on 03/01/05 at 3:44 pm
Patti LaBelle would probably be good too. And I would LOVE to see Prince as a judge. THAT might even get me to watch the show once.
Subject: Re: Who should judge "American Idol" if Paula Abdul was to leave...
Written By: Indy Gent on 03/01/05 at 3:53 pm
Other: John Mellencamp
Subject: Re: Who should judge "American Idol" if Paula Abdul was to leave...
Written By: NullandVoid on 03/01/05 at 4:00 pm
I picked Madonna, I think she'd put Simon in his place.
Subject: Re: Who should judge "American Idol" if Paula Abdul was to leave...
Written By: Tanya1976 on 03/01/05 at 7:10 pm
I pick Toni Braxton.
It would have to be someone with great singing pipes. While I love Madonna as a performer, she's not a singer, honestly. Taylor Dayne would be my second choice.
Tanya
Subject: Re: Who should judge "American Idol" if Paula Abdul was to leave...
Written By: Jennifer028 on 03/01/05 at 9:58 pm
Whitney Houston would be interesting. Also George Michael. :)
Subject: Re: Who should judge "American Idol" if Paula Abdul was to leave...
Written By: kairi747 on 03/21/05 at 12:29 am
me? ;)
Subject: Re: Who should judge "American Idol" if Paula Abdul was to leave...
Written By: AL-B on 03/21/05 at 12:50 am
James Hetfield from Metallica. He'd be ruthless! ;D
Subject: Re: Who should judge "American Idol" if Paula Abdul was to leave...
Written By: Dagwood on 03/21/05 at 7:20 am
Not that she does much anyway but coddle them. ::)
I picked Weird Al just because it would be fun.
Subject: Re: Who should judge "American Idol" if Paula Abdul was to leave...
Written By: kairi747 on 03/21/05 at 9:31 am
I picked Madonna, I think she'd put Simon in his place.
so you would like to replace one singer who can't sing with another singer who can't sing? makes sense to me! :D