I think the best singing was probably Carrie Underwood. Celena, Amanda, and Lindsey are hotties. Carrie isn't bad either. Actually most of them look pretty good. This is a good crop of girls this year.

I like Carrie Underwood and Nadia the best.  Mikayla needs to go now.  That girl bugs the heck out of me.  She talks like Fran Drescher, someone needs to tell her that's not a good thing.

She is really nasal, isn't she.  Hard to believe she's only 16, she doesn't look or act it.  Not familiar enough with them to remember most of their names.  I'm with the judges thou, I don't know why most of them picked ballads to sing when it's obvious that people really enjoy the up beat stuff more.

I only vote for the ones who I think can actually sing.  That's why I'm so glad Carrie did really good cuz it's about time we had an Okie on American Idol.  I also voted for Nadia and Aloha. 

let them all audition for the new Hummer commercial

Some of the girls are good. Carrie is good as a country singer. She will be tested when other genres come in. Being an one-trick pony can kill ya.

Tanya

Some of the girls are good. Carrie is good as a country singer. She will be tested when other genres come in. Being an one-trick pony can kill ya.

Tanya
tell me about it, I didn't get far singing Death Metal

Some of the girls are good. Carrie is good as a country singer. She will be tested when other genres come in. Being an one-trick pony can kill ya.

Tanya



I don't think she sounds like pure country.  I can definitely hear some good pop elements in her voice and I think she'll be able to do good.

We get this show in the UK a few days after it's shown in the USA. I saw the girls part of the show last night, I thought Nadia was head and shoulders above anyone else in the competition.

BORING!  The girls are so much less fun to watch than the boys.  I do like Carrie and Nadia, but even they aren't very exciting!

I don't like Carrie Underwood at all I guess it's because I hate country music and she doesn't seem to be the brightest person but the girls are seriously pathetic compared to the guys this season. I like Nadia and Vonzell and I hope Mikalah dies. I have no idea why the judges like her horrible annoying screeching voice so much.  >:(

I saw the girls part of the show last night, I thought Nadia was head and shoulders above anyone else in the competition.

I totally agree!  :)

I don't think she sounds like pure country.  I can definitely hear some good pop elements in her voice and I think she'll be able to do good.


She has a good voice, no doubt about it. But, it seems almost every song has a country tinge to it.

Tanya

Bunch of hotties...

Bunch of hotties...
Why does that sound so perverted?  :-\\

I like Mikalya.....she is really pretty....but looks way too old to be only 16...she has a very unique singing voice


Erin :)

Personally I like Carrie, she sang a heart song like it was made for her.

I don't give a fying fluck about the American Idol girls, whoever they are!
:P

I like Mikalya.....she is really pretty....but looks way too old to be only 16...she has a very unique singing voice

Erin :)



Yeah she's pretty, but she sings like somethings blocking her windpipe.  I personally think she'd have a better chance winning Next Top Model than America Idol. 

This week, Carrie was definitely my favorite.  I also voted for Nadia the past few weeks, but she really disappointed me this time....after time.... Her voice just isn't that strong.  And what the blankety-bleep was up with the fro-hawk???

Meh, I'm kinda sick of American Idol at this point.

Even though I'm not really too happy with the girls this season, I would have to pick Carrie Underwood and Nadia. However Ms. Underwood should definitely try to look more alive onstage and Nadia should NEVER EVER wear a fauxhawk again.

Even though I'm not really too happy with the girls this season, I would have to pick Carrie Underwood and Nadia. However Ms. Underwood should definitely try to look more alive onstage and Nadia should NEVER EVER wear a fauxhawk again.


I do agree- Carrie's great vocals need to be accompanied with a little better stage presence.

btw, was anyone else at mad as I was when Mario left?

I do agree- Carrie's great vocals need to be accompanied with a little better stage presence.

btw, was anyone else at mad as I was when Mario left?


Yeah I was burnt too, I think he had a 90% chance of winning it. Then again American Idol Alumni usually have a one year shelf life so maybe it was a good thing for him.

I do agree- Carrie's great vocals need to be accompanied with a little better stage presence.

btw, was anyone else at mad as I was when Mario left?


yes!  i miss mario.  rumor has it - he signed a contract with p diddy.  we shall see!

Yeah she's pretty, but she sings like somethings blocking her windpipe.  I personally think she'd have a better chance winning Next Top Model than America Idol.   

This week, Carrie was definitely my favorite.  I also voted for Nadia the past few weeks, but she really disappointed me this time....after time.... Her voice just isn't that strong.  And what the blankety-bleep was up with the fro-hawk???

I agree 100% QueenAmenRa, I liked Mikayla's personality and she gave some decent performances on earlier shows but this week she sang really flat, it was terrible.

Nadia was my early favourite but again I agree, this week she really disappointed.