» OLD MESSAGE ARCHIVES «
The Pop Culture Information Society...
Messageboard Archive Index, In The 00s - The Pop Culture Information Society

Welcome to the archived messages from In The 00s. This archive stretches back to 1998 in some instances, and contains a nearly complete record of all the messages posted to inthe00s.com. You will also find an archive of the messages from inthe70s.com, inthe80s.com, inthe90s.com and amiright.com before they were combined to form the inthe00s.com messageboard.

If you are looking for the active messages, please click here. Otherwise, use the links below or on the right hand side of the page to navigate the archives.

Custom Search



Subject: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/16/04 at 08:59 a.m.

 If this post offends anyone in anyway, I sincerely apologize, but I see several injustices regarding treatment of those with chronic mental disorders/illness that I feel need to be addressed
 Feel free to disagree with me.

1. People with chronic mental disorders and illness, have in my Libertarian viewpoint, Every Right to Peacefully take their own lives(commit suicide)without physically hurting anyone else.
Of course the decision should NOT be made on the spur of the moment, but to expect people to live their whole lives dependant upon Psychiatric drugs, in my opinion is barbaric and inhumane,Cruel and unjust
And , the Government/Mental Health Profession should provide these people with a Quick,Effective, and not too painful method for ending their lives, the same way, as let's say, if they were Old and had a Terminal illness
 What gives the Government or Mental Health Profession the Right, who the heck are they to tell those suffering that they can't take their own lives without physically hurting anyone else?

2. Until those with Chronic Mental Disorders and illnesses are Granted the Right to Take their own lives without physically hurting anyone else, they will Never be truly free and equal citizens. They will continue to be unjustly oppressed.

3. A friend of mine from High school is Schizophrenic and lives in a Group home, he has to share a Room, with a Roomate.
All people in "Group Homes" should be allowed to have a Small room entirely to themselves, and be able to have a Color TV/VCR in it, and Privacy,
so it would be like they live on their own. And close to Normalcy as possible

4. My Schizophenic friend has to go to a "Day Program" Yet if an Elderly (Non-Mentally ill) person had to live in a Group Home
would that person be Forced unjustly to go to some sort of day program, why the Discrimination against my Schizophrenic friend.

5. I and many others have said this MANY times, Social Security Gives Disability "Benefits" to the Disabled, but how are the Disabled supposed to live on SSI alone?
Can they Get Welfare(Public Assistance) with it's two checks a Month, Plus the Social Security check.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/16/04 at 09:17 a.m.

This should be an important topic for all Americans in the 21st century

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 01/16/04 at 09:23 a.m.

I,myself attend IPRT which is an acronym for Intense Psychiatric Rehabiliation Treatment)A program that will probably elp me get a job.And I do get SSI.2 checks a month. :D


Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/16/04 at 10:03 a.m.

If you don't mind me asking..

What is the Program like

And how does it work SSI, two checks a Month, do you work?
I thought SSI was one check a month,
do you get public assistance(welfare) also?
How do you live on such small income,
Do you pay taxes?

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/16/04 at 10:09 a.m.

Their are some people who care more about
Animal Rights, than the rights of fellow human beings with mental disorders and illness.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/16/04 at 10:54 a.m.

We must realize that...

Any Human Being No matter how stable or well off, given the right circumstances would take his/her own life(commit suicide) We all have our different levels of endurance and perserverance.
For example imagine if you were in the same shoes as Jonathan Brandis(Seaquest DSV) or Elliot Smith, or the wife of the late Phil Hartman.

We are all basically at the Mercy of the savage/unpredicatable nature of this world we live in/look at the Horrific Earthquake in Iran, or the Staten Island Ferry Tragedy.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/16/04 at 10:55 a.m.

Ironically,
I have read that MANY Psychiatrists commit suicide, I think that in is the United States as well.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/16/04 at 12:14 a.m.

Two Words: Greater Flexibility

For those suffering from Mental Disorders/illness.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Thunderbolt on 01/16/04 at 02:26 p.m.

Who makes the decision to place one in such a home?

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: NullandVoid on 01/16/04 at 02:49 p.m.

I know I'm a little off topic here, but I am totally in shock-I did not know that Jonathan Brandis was dead! OMG.... :'(

I used to love him

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Hairspray on 01/16/04 at 05:02 p.m.

Quoting:
 If this post offends anyone in anyway, I sincerely apologize, but I see several injustices regarding treatment of those with chronic mental disorders/illness that I feel need to be addressed
 Feel free to disagree with me.

1. People with chronic mental disorders and illness, have in my Libertarian viewpoint, Every Right to Peacefully take their own lives(commit suicide)without physically hurting anyone else.
Of course the decision should NOT be made on the spur of the moment, but to expect people to live their whole lives dependant upon Psychiatric drugs, in my opinion is barbaric and inhumane,Cruel and unjust
And , the Government/Mental Health Profession should provide these people with a Quick,Effective, and not too painful method for ending their lives, the same way, as let's say, if they were Old and had a Terminal illness
 What gives the Government or Mental Health Profession the Right, who the heck are they to tell those suffering that they can't take their own lives without physically hurting anyone else?End Quote



Ok.

I'm a little confused because you say you're Christian, yet I see your views on this issue as unorthodox.

I just would like to point out that suicide is against most Christian's moral code.

As far as your first point on suicide goes -

A person wanting to commit suicide "without physically hurting anyone else" should consider the emotional pain they could potentially cause their family and friends.

Emotional pain can be just as painful, just as hurtful and just as deep as physical pain.

Then again, a person who is suicidal has unaddressed issues to begin with and may not have the presence of mind to think of the consequences of their actions and are on "selfish mode", thinking only of themselves.

More on topic:

I do not believe the mentally ill have the mental capacity to make such decisions regarding life and death.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 01/17/04 at 10:57 a.m.


Quoting:
If you don't mind me asking..

What is the Program like

And how does it work SSI, two checks a Month, do you work?
I thought SSI was one check a month,
do you get public assistance(welfare) also?
How do you live on such small income,
Do you pay taxes?
End Quote



This program Andrew is to help me try to get my life back together and SSI checks I get once a month for benefits and you don't have a job yet you get government money.


Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 01/17/04 at 12:08 a.m.

Quoting:
People with chronic mental disorders and illness, have in my Libertarian viewpoint, Every Right to Peacefully take their own lives(commit suicide)without physically hurting anyone else.End Quote



The problem here Andrew is knowing if the patient is under the influence of the mental illness at the time of requesting something like euthanasia.

To add: I wrote this before reading Hairspray's post fully . . . Sorry.  :-[ ;D

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: NASCARnut on 01/17/04 at 05:56 p.m.

As a disABLED person with Schizoaffective Disorder and OCD, I must say that SUICIDE SOLVES NOTHING! I have tried it five times, and each time I've been saved by compassionate people who are in the helping professions. Your friends stop caring after awhile because you have betrayed their friendship. And as far as medications go,modern meds such as Seroquel,Abilify,Prozac,and Zyprexa have few side effects. And rather than going to a partial-care day program,I get my meds from a psychiatric social work team that has a 'shrink' on staff. For medical and social things I attend Atlantic Adult Day Health Care,which is a loosely structured program with a wide range of activities. 8)

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 01/18/04 at 10:40 a.m.

I was diagnosed with OCD (Obsessive Compulsive Disorder)and it used to affect me but now I'm glad I don't take medication anymore. :)


Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 01/18/04 at 12:36 a.m.

How did OCD (Obsessive Compulsive Disorder) affect your life, NascarNut and Howard? I've heard the cliches (Washing hands continuously, arranging things in order of size, colour etc . . .). Is it really like that or is it something more complex?

Hope you don't mind me asking.  :)

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 01/18/04 at 03:56 p.m.

I am a sufferer of depression and anxiety who has given up asking for help. My doctor has put me on medication in the past and nothing's worked so far. I refuse to talk to her about it anymore because she's of the mindset that the reason I have the problems I do is because I'm unemployed, and that getting a job will make it all better. What she doesn't understand is, I was miserable working as well. I would take days off or leave early sick because I was too depressed. But as far as suicide goes, I have thought about it millions and millions of times, but I've been too chicken to try it. I want help. I don't want to kill myself. I realise my husband and my Guinea Pigs will miss me, and I'm too scared of death that I'd rather meet it later than sooner.

Yes, people have every right to do whatever they want with their lives. If they think they're that much in pain that they're beyond help and they want to commit suicide, that's their choice. Other people will be affected, yes, but it was that person's choice to commit suicide. Is it selfish? Of course it is, but I can understand not wanting to go through the hurt, pain and anguish ever again...nor having to burden other people with their problems. It's only natural to feel that way. You think people will only get sick and tired of you whinging about your problems, yet you don't want to keep them inside otherwise you'll self-destruct. And you don't want to live like that, so what's the most obvious solution? Suicide. A suicidal person, in my opinion, is essentially thinking they're doing other people a favour by killing themselves because they think they won't be bothering anyone anymore. Again, yes, it's selfish thinking, but they don't want to burden anyone...even so-called menal health professionals...with their problems because they believe they are beyond repair.

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 01/18/04 at 06:17 p.m.

Quoting:
I am a sufferer of depression and anxiety who has given up asking for help. My doctor has put me on medication in the past and nothing's worked so far. I refuse to talk to her about it anymore because she's of the mindset that the reason I have the problems I do is because I'm unemployed, and that getting a job will make it all better. What she doesn't understand is, I was miserable working as well. I would take days off or leave early sick because I was too depressed. But as far as suicide goes, I have thought about it millions and millions of times, but I've been too chicken to try it. I want help. I don't want to kill myself. I realise my husband and my Guinea Pigs will miss me, and I'm too scared of death that I'd rather meet it later than sooner.

Absolutely Vile
End Quote



Vile. Do you believe your depression is biological (a physical problem in the brain) or circumstantial (a problem related to outside influences e.g a death in the family etc)?

Why I ask is my depression was circumstantial and the doctor put me on pills. They didn't help me. I was very cynical even at the young age of 17 and thought the doctor was fobbing me off with The Placebo Effect (giving me fake pills in the hope that I would get better because I believe they will make me better). I felt that it didn't matter how many pills I took, it would only cloud the problem rather than fix it. It was only until I realised and accepted what had happened to me that I can now move on.

Please tell me if I have got the wrong end of the stick.  :)

Just to add: Get yourself a counsellor that cares. The one you have been seeing is obviously inept - I saw a counsellor 3 years ago who was wonderful. I saw my meetings with her as a breakthrough in my recovery.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 01/19/04 at 11:53 a.m.


Quoting:
How did OCD (Obsessive Compulsive Disorder) affect your life, NascarNut and Howard? I've heard the cliches (Washing hands continuously, arranging things in order of size, colour etc . . .). Is it really like that or is it something more complex?

Hope you don't mind me asking.  :)
End Quote



I think it started at my paying job at Genovese.I was working as a porter and sometimes I'd see open bags of M&M's and pop a few of them in my mouth but the real reason I got fired was my compulsion to steal.It was in 1993.I was put on medications Anafranil & Prozacfor 6 years I was on it.I always kept looking back to see if I left things behind,checking garbages for food :P,plucking eyebrows(not with tweezer) :( out of nervous anxiety.I was finally taken off it in July of 1999 cause I felt much better and the anxiety lessened but not by much. :)

Howard


Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Claude_Prez on 01/19/04 at 07:45 p.m.


Quoting:
 If this post offends anyone in anyway, I sincerely apologize, but I see several injustices regarding treatment of those with chronic mental disorders/illness that I feel need to be addressed
 Feel free to disagree with me.

1. People with chronic mental disorders and illness, have in my Libertarian viewpoint, Every Right to Peacefully take their own lives(commit suicide)without physically hurting anyone else.
Of course the decision should NOT be made on the spur of the moment, but to expect people to live their whole lives dependant upon Psychiatric drugs, in my opinion is barbaric and inhumane,Cruel and unjust
And , the Government/Mental Health Profession should provide these people with a Quick,Effective, and not too painful method for ending their lives, the same way, as let's say, if they were Old and had a Terminal illness
 What gives the Government or Mental Health Profession the Right, who the heck are they to tell those suffering that they can't take their own lives without physically hurting anyone else?

2. Until those with Chronic Mental Disorders and illnesses are Granted the Right to Take their own lives without physically hurting anyone else, they will Never be truly free and equal citizens. They will continue to be unjustly oppressed.

3. A friend of mine from High school is Schizophrenic and lives in a Group home, he has to share a Room, with a Roomate.
All people in "Group Homes" should be allowed to have a Small room entirely to themselves, and be able to have a Color TV/VCR in it, and Privacy,
so it would be like they live on their own. And close to Normalcy as possible

4. My Schizophenic friend has to go to a "Day Program" Yet if an Elderly (Non-Mentally ill) person had to live in a Group Home
would that person be Forced unjustly to go to some sort of day program, why the Discrimination against my Schizophrenic friend.

5. I and many others have said this MANY times, Social Security Gives Disability "Benefits" to the Disabled, but how are the Disabled supposed to live on SSI alone?
Can they Get Welfare(Public Assistance) with it's two checks a Month, Plus the Social Security check.
End Quote


I'm sorry; I just can't let this go by without pointing out that there's nothing "Libertarian" about demanding stuff from the government.  No offense; wish you well and all that but as someone who usually votes Libertarian when possible I can guarantee you their whole schtick is to generally reduce spending programs, not increase them as you call for repeatedly in this post.  Unless you were joking, in which case jolly good one then.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 01/20/04 at 03:57 a.m.

Quoting:
I think it started at my paying job at Genovese.I was working as a porter and sometimes I'd see open bags of M&M's and pop a few of them in my mouth but the real reason I got fired was my compulsion to steal.It was in 1993.I was put on medications Anafranil & Prozacfor 6 years I was on it.I always kept looking back to see if I left things behind,checking garbages for food :P,plucking eyebrows(not with tweezer) :( out of nervous anxiety.I was finally taken off it in July of 1999 cause I felt much better and the anxiety lessened but not by much. :)

Howard
End Quote



Ah I see. Thanks for sharing that, Howard. I'm glad you feel much better.  :)

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/20/04 at 10:16 a.m.

Yes, However, in America
one form of murder(abortion) is perfectly legal.

Yet it is not legal for someone with a chronic mental disorder/illness to commit suicide without physically hurting anyone else.
Of course the decision should NOT be made on the spur of the moment.

It is disgusting that those with chronic mental disorders and illness,(those that have life the hardest)are forbidden from taking thier own lives,
In this book, someone once argued, the Government/Health Profession should provide the end of life method, to make it more humane. And dignified.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/20/04 at 10:26 a.m.

To those of you who had or still have a chronic mental disorder or illness I ask you

If you had a choice between having the illness or illnesses you have and Not being born(non-existence) which would you choose.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: LyricBoy on 01/20/04 at 10:31 a.m.


Quoting:
To those of you who had or still have a chronic mental disorder or illness I ask you

If you had a choice between having the illness or illnesses you have and Not being born(non-existence) which would you choose.
End Quote



Having been depressed most of my life, I can still say that I would rather be how I am than to not be at all.

My belief is that in life, if you are making the world a better place (help people in their lives) because you are in it, then you are being successful.  Every day, despite depression, I have the opportunity to help people and make the world a better place.  So I continue to fulfill my destiny.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Hairspray on 01/20/04 at 12:36 a.m.

Andrew,

If you're looking for strong support for suicide in this forum, I don't believe you're going to find it at this point.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/20/04 at 02:55 p.m.

Yes, but in the past,
Many Decades ago, before the 1950's
before the invention of Psychiatric Drugs, people with Mental illness/disorders in hospitals were prevented from taking their own lives,
such misery and pain, they must have endured,

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 01/20/04 at 05:56 p.m.


Quoting:


Ah I see. Thanks for sharing that, Howard. I'm glad you feel much better.  :)
End Quote



Thank You Bob.I hope it doesn't come back anymore. :(


Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 01/21/04 at 08:06 a.m.

Quoting:


Vile. Do you believe your depression is biological (a physical problem in the brain) or circumstantial (a problem related to outside influences e.g a death in the family etc)?

Why I ask is my depression was circumstantial and the doctor put me on pills. They didn't help me. I was very cynical even at the young age of 17 and thought the doctor was fobbing me off with The Placebo Effect (giving me fake pills in the hope that I would get better because I believe they will make me better). I felt that it didn't matter how many pills I took, it would only cloud the problem rather than fix it. It was only until I realised and accepted what had happened to me that I can now move on.

Please tell me if I have got the wrong end of the stick.  :)

Just to add: Get yourself a counsellor that cares. The one you have been seeing is obviously inept - I saw a counsellor 3 years ago who was wonderful. I saw my meetings with her as a breakthrough in my recovery.
End Quote



You know...I have no idea. There's no history of it in my family that I'm aware of. But then again, that seems like a strange thing to ask your parents!! "Are you depressed?" I do have a suspicion that my dad could have something because he and I have a lot of the same sort of characteristics, and he actually understands what I go through, unlike my mum, but I feel weird about asking him about it. At the same time though, I can see it being circumstantial because I've had a lot happen in my life (being disabled, being bothered by kids at school when I was a teenager because of it, alcoholic dad, dad leaving all of a sudden when my brother and I were at school, being rejected rejected constantly by the opposite sex, etc., etc., etc...). I suppose the only way I'm ever going to find out is through the process of elimination, which would mean talking to my parents about it. Eep.

My GP is actually the one that's prescribed me pills. But I don't want to even talk to her about it again because I don't believe she thinks there's anything really wrong. I was in therapy for a year, and it was really great to have someone to talk to, but obviously it didn't help as much as it should have. I've only seen a psychiatrist once, and he put me on the same pills my doctor put me on previously. They didn't work. Our schedules clashed and I ended up not going back. I wouldn't have anyway, because he ran his practice from his flat which was a bit creepy. I've also talked to a psychiatric nurse who told me I didn't need a diagnosis (no clue why), and that I should try both going on pills and talk therapy. I still have yet to do that. The last lot of pills I was on (Celexa) made me lethargic so I'm off them and haven't been on anything since. Once I get put on something that works, I'll consider therapy again.

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 01/21/04 at 08:13 a.m.

Quoting:
To those of you who had or still have a chronic mental disorder or illness I ask you

If you had a choice between having the illness or illnesses you have and Not being born(non-existence) which would you choose.
End Quote



Depends how I feel. Sometimes I feel like doing something about my depression/anxiety, and sometimes I wish I was dead or never born. Usually, I feel like getting myself sorted. It's just a matter of finding proper help. It's normally when I have my severe bouts of depression that I wish I were never here...

Absolutely Vile

I don't wanna die. I sometimes wish I'd never been born at all.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: NASCARnut on 01/22/04 at 00:07 a.m.


Quoting:


Ah I see. Thanks for sharing that, Howard. I'm glad you feel much better.  :)
End Quote

My OCD comes out as picking at my ears until they are red and raw,a compulsion to overeat when I feel bad AND when I feel good,having to have everyday events in my life the way I want them,to the point of meltdown when I don't get my way or things go wrong! I am getting better at dealing with life on its terms with the help of a great psychiatrist and 40 mg of Prozac daily. But that's not to say that I don't have bad days,everyone does,that's life. I deal the best I can under my circumstances.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: NASCARnut on 01/22/04 at 00:22 a.m.


Quoting:
To those of you who had or still have a chronic mental disorder or illness I ask you

If you had a choice between having the illness or illnesses you have and Not being born(non-existence) which would you choose.
End Quote

I would still choose life. Like I said before, I have both mental illness and physical problems,but I still lead an active and fulfilling life. I have had life experiences I wouldn't trade for anything! I have worked at an Atlantic City casino,gone to a church youth group with other disABLED(accent on ABLED)people,trained others computer skills on a volunteer basis,been a speaker at mental health rallies and consumer conferences. At my adult day care program,there are people worse off than I am,and they STILL are somewhat independent and live their lives to the fullest. I'm happy to count these people,young and old,as my friends. I have a wonderful apartment mate and a sweet Calico cat named Tika. Had I not been born,what a bunch of missed opportunities. ::)

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 01/23/04 at 03:44 a.m.

Quoting:
My OCD comes out as picking at my ears until they are red and raw,a compulsion to overeat when I feel bad AND when I feel good,having to have everyday events in my life the way I want them,to the point of meltdown when I don't get my way or things go wrong! I am getting better at dealing with life on its terms with the help of a great psychiatrist and 40 mg of Prozac daily. But that's not to say that I don't have bad days,everyone does,that's life. I deal the best I can under my circumstances.
End Quote



You know, Nascarnut, I used to have the problem of needing everything going my way - especially socially. Sometimes it would be the end of the world for me if someone said the wrong thing - even when I was in a good mood and would trigger off an 'inner thinking' episode where I would question my value as a human. I don't know why I should think like this. I am trying to make my skin a little thicker.  ;)

The fact that you deal with your situation makes you a strong, brave person. Mental illness can be the worst battle anyone has . . . Ironically it is with ourselves.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 01/23/04 at 03:49 a.m.

Quoting:
Having been depressed most of my life, I can still say that I would rather be how I am than to not be at all.

My belief is that in life, if you are making the world a better place (help people in their lives) because you are in it, then you are being successful.  Every day, despite depression, I have the opportunity to help people and make the world a better place.  So I continue to fulfill my destiny.
End Quote



That's a great attitude to have, Lyricboy. If you were never born at all, you would never know if you would make a difference.

I'll tell you something, I felt really bad in 1997/1998 and I was close to just 'packing it all in' so to speak.

We are now in 2004 and I have a wonderful girlfriend, a nice steady income and a greater outlook on life. If I did myself in then, how would I know if I was going to achieve happiness?

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/23/04 at 09:02 a.m.

I think, the Ben Stiller character in
"Along came Polly" had OCD.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/23/04 at 09:04 a.m.

Someone once said, after seeing
"The Cat in the Hat"
That elements of OCD are in it, the fear of Germs,handwashing.

A superb book on OCD is,

"The Boy who couldn't stop washing"

Everyone's OCD is different.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/23/04 at 09:05 a.m.

 Does lovely actress
Cameron Diaz, suffer from OCD, I heard she does
Maybe she should go public with it
like
Marc Summers, from Double Dare.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 01/23/04 at 09:21 a.m.

When I started my OCD,I had weird obsessions and thoughts:

plucking my eyebrows
looking in garbages for food  ???
checking back to see if I had left things twice.

But,you know I'm feeling much better these days and the thoughts have lessened. :)

Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/25/04 at 10:45 a.m.

Again, I state,
that until those with chronic mental disorders/illness, are granted the right to take their own lives without physically hurting anyone else, they shall never be truly free.
 The Government IMO should provide a humane method, don't get me wrong the decision should NOT be made on the spur of the moment.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 01/25/04 at 11:39 a.m.

Quoting:
Again, I state,
that until those with chronic mental disorders/illness, are granted the right to take their own lives without physically hurting anyone else, they shall never be truly free.
 The Government IMO should provide a humane method, don't get me wrong the decision should NOT be made on the spur of the moment.
End Quote



What do you think makes people free in death? Free from problems? We all have to face problems in life regardless of their severity. The courage is in continuing on, not by giving up.

I hear you mention the afterlife on the threads a lot and are quite religious. This has been mentioned previously but I would like to embellish it a little. If it is a sin to commit suicide in any form, then in theory and on your own terms, wouldn't mentally ill people forfeit their right to an 'afterlife'?

You would have to say 'People are only free if they want to choose whether they would like an afterlife or not'.  ???

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/26/04 at 10:03 a.m.

Yes, but my point is that it is Barbaric, and cruel and unjust for the Government or Mental Health Profession to expect people  to live
years and decades on end, dependant upon Psychiatric Drugs their whole lives.
Those with chronic mental disorders have every Right to Rebel against the Government and Mental Health Profession, supreme rebellion by commiting suicide without Physically hurting anyone else. They have every right to be Freedom Fighters.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 01/26/04 at 10:22 a.m.

Why lobby for the legalisation of suicide and the providing of a safe, humane way of ending one's life? First of all, there is a safe, humane way. It's called carbon monoxide poisoning. It's slow, but it gets the job done. All you do is go to sleep. And what's the government going to do? Prosecute a dead body? Come on!!! Don't be ridiculous.

I, personally, would rather concentrate on getting well rather than ending my life. But just wait 'til I have a severe bout of depression. I might change my mind. But I've had several of them, and I'm still here! I've always gotten through! If you don't want to get help, that's your choice, and not my problem or anyone else's.

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/26/04 at 03:33 p.m.

Yes, but another example of Discrimination against those with Mental Disorders/illness,

If someone with a Physical Problem was living in a Nursing home, they wouldn't be required to go to a day program like someone with a Mental disorder or illness/such discrimination
A "Day Program" would be Forced upon someone with a Mental disorder or illness.
Why the Double Standard??

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/26/04 at 03:36 p.m.

  Just curious, If a Christian commits suicide, do they still go to Heaven, ?
I have come across convincing evidence that they still do.

St.John Cyrsotoym of the 4th century, had alot of compassion, I wonder what he would say?

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/26/04 at 03:42 p.m.

What's Wrong with my message,
"Will Anti-Semitism ever end"??

I can't seem to open it. It says unable to open

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/26/04 at 03:49 p.m.

 Does anyone remember the name of that
"JAG" star that commited suicide last year,
what cause him/her to commit suicide.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/26/04 at 03:52 p.m.

 Someone once said

For all people with Chronic Mental Disorders/illness, if they want they should have acess to the Gamma Knife(Laser Brain Surgery) Free of Charge,
Even if they do well on Meds, that way, after the surgery(although experimental) they would do even better on Meds, or Not even need them at all.  Wouldn't that be Great.
The Government/Mental Health Profession must eradicate Mental illness, and disorders once and for all.

And, it would Benefit, BOTH people with Mental Disorders and Society, Common Sense people?
 I have always wondered, why do so many Psychiatrists commit suicide, is this true in America also?

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/26/04 at 03:53 p.m.

My Mom said,

"You would be surprised how many people take Psychiatric Drugs, (see Psychiatrists) people from all walks of life.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/26/04 at 04:33 p.m.

 Another terrible tragedy is that America is Jailing the Mentally ill,

It is obscene, how cruel and inhumane the Prison and Jail systems are in America,
and when you keep in mind, that the Majority of people in Prison are their for Non-Violent(Drug Offenses)
Even Prisoners deserve a Safe,Sanitary,Humane environment.
After all Prison Violence and Rape, turns Non-Violent offenders into Violent offenders, when they are released.
Look at the Beast Saddam Hussein, he is getting Humane treatment, probably better than many Americans in Jail/Prison for Non-Violent offenses,
 That and George W. Bush continues to waste Government money on the Space Program, we need more money and funds, for helping the common man, and for eliminating Disease.

See the website www.SPR.org

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/26/04 at 04:43 p.m.

Speaking of mental illness,
Many people with Mental disorders/illness get Medicaid,
Am I the only one that thinks the Government should pay for people to get Laser Eye surgery.

I know many people, Men and Women, who wear small glasses, yet STILL, it makes a Huge Difference in their facial looks, with as opposed to without glasses.

Does laser eye surgery prevent the eyes from becoming nearsided.

 Again, Regarding Mental Illness, their must be some way to permanently correct the chemical imbalance in the Brain.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 01/26/04 at 05:35 p.m.

Quoting:
Speaking of mental illness,
Many people with Mental disorders/illness get Medicaid,
Am I the only one that thinks the Government should pay for people to get Laser Eye surgery.

I know many people, Men and Women, who wear small glasses, yet STILL, it makes a Huge Difference in their facial looks, with as opposed to without glasses.

Does laser eye surgery prevent the eyes from becoming nearsided.

 Again, Regarding Mental Illness, their must be some way to permanently correct the chemical imbalance in the Brain.
End Quote



Shouldn't lazer eye surgery be another thread entirely?

As for correcting chemical imbalances in the brain, that was what I thought anti-depressants and beta blockers do.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/26/04 at 05:43 p.m.

Speaking of oppression of those with chronic Mental Disorders/illness,

A superb article was written by
Christopher Slobogin in 2002, for the New York Newsday

Don't Target Mental illness in Gun Checks.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/26/04 at 05:46 p.m.

To those of you who struggle with mental disorders/illness, do you ever think, that you are fighting a losing battle?

I feel sorry for Michael J. Fox, having Parkinson's disease, I wonder if he ever thinks he is fighting a losing battle against the disease, if so he will put up a good fight.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Hairspray on 01/26/04 at 10:03 p.m.


Quoting:
To those of you who struggle with mental disorders/illness...End Quote



I don't struggle with a mental disorders or illness, but I feel sorry that you do; especially seeing how much you struggle with it. :-/

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/27/04 at 11:06 a.m.

Why don't More people with Chronic Mental Disorders/illness,
petition the Government and Mental Health Profession to Grant them THE most fundamental Right,
The Right to commit Suicide without Physically hurting anyone else,
It is Unreasonable, doesn't anyone else think that it is for the Mental Health Profession/Gov't to expect people to live for decades dependant upon Psychiatric Drugs.

Mental Health Professionals may seem nice, but when they prevent those with chronic Mental disorders and illness from commiting suicide without physically hurting anyone else,
They are Hurting rather than helping,
they are "Just following orders"

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/27/04 at 12:33 a.m.

Do any of you blame your parents for your mental disorders/illness?

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 01/27/04 at 03:12 p.m.

Quoting:
Do any of you blame your parents for your mental disorders/illness?
End Quote



Heh heh. An interesting question and one that can only be answered individually. For me, my parents contributed to the way I felt in a large way. I believe that my depression was circumstantial and was a reaction to outside events.

Andrew. I saw Hairspray's post. May I ask, without offending you, if you do have an illness?

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 01/27/04 at 03:47 p.m.

Quoting:
Why don't More people with Chronic Mental Disorders/illness,
petition the Government and Mental Health Profession to Grant them THE most fundamental Right,
The Right to commit Suicide without Physically hurting anyone else,
It is Unreasonable, doesn't anyone else think that it is for the Mental Health Profession/Gov't to expect people to live for decades dependant upon Psychiatric Drugs.

Mental Health Professionals may seem nice, but when they prevent those with chronic Mental disorders and illness from commiting suicide without physically hurting anyone else,
They are Hurting rather than helping,
they are "Just following orders"
End Quote



ARGH!!! Do you not think, for one moment, that maybe some mentally ill people want to live?? What makes you think we all want to die? I know you're probably just trying to keep our options open. But I think if someone wants to commit suicide, they're going to do it, whether it's illegal or not, whether it's unethical or not, whether it hurts someone they love or not. They're not going to give a sh*t about anything. I also don't know how suicide could be illegal because you can't prosecute a dead body. I know assisted suicide is illegal even if the person wanting to die is terminally ill, which in most if not all cases, he or she is. So are you saying that mentally ill people are terminal? No they're not. They can get help. Which brings me to my next point...

Mental health professionals are there to help you. If you're seeing one that just seems like he or she is just "doing their job," then go find someone else. There are ones who genuinely care. They don't want to see you off yourself as much as anyone else. As for being on medication for the rest of your life...well, some people have to be. People with severe mental disorders like schizophrenia must be on medication for the rest of their lives otherwise they may become a danger to society if their condition worsens. People with all mental illnesses, no matter how severe, have just as much right to live as anyone else! And a lot of them want to live normal, healthy, active lives!!

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 01/27/04 at 06:13 p.m.

Well said Vile.  :)

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 01/27/04 at 06:40 p.m.


Quoting:
Do any of you blame your parents for your mental disorders/illness?
End Quote



I shouldn't blame my parents.Maybe blame myself. :-[ :(


Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/28/04 at 09:06 a.m.

In the Afterlife, do Personality Disorders, that people have Disappear along with other Mental and physical conditions that exist in Earthly life.?

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 01/28/04 at 10:26 a.m.


Quoting:
In the Afterlife, do Personality Disorders, that people have Disappear along with other Mental and physical conditions that exist in Earthly life.?
End Quote



What the hell are you talking about? ??? ??? >:(

What's with this afterlife you keep referring to?  ???

make sense,will ya? ??? >:(


Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/28/04 at 10:28 a.m.

It's High time that Disability Advocates take on the Social Security Administration,
More Money,and Services should be given to the Disabled.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 01/28/04 at 10:30 a.m.


Quoting:
It's High time that Disability Advocates take on the Social Security Administration,
More Money,and Services should be given to the Disabled.
End Quote



I'm just trying to get your posts to make sense.I have no idea why you keep bringing up The Afterlife in most of them. ??? >:(


Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Hairspray on 01/28/04 at 10:45 a.m.

Andrew,

it doesn't seem like you read Absolutely Vile's most excellent post. It's a shame because you should. Vile makes excellent points in reference to this subject.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: AndrewTalkingWalnut on 01/28/04 at 01:54 p.m.

I mention the Afterlife, because it is my Hope, that all human beings that ever lived, will Eventually be in Heaven,
that their will be a Human Existence Free from suffering, and all the pain of my fellow human beings will end.
 When I see people with Mental and/or Physical ailments, I think, that's NOT FAIR!
I wish God would eliminate all sickness and suffering, Let's face it, although it's the 21st century, Medical Technology that exists today is still Painfully Primitive,

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 01/28/04 at 04:12 p.m.

Andrew.

Maybe I am speaking from a non theological point of view but what happens if the 'afterlife' is not as you had expected? Maybe it is different in ways that you couldn't imagine or what if there is no afterlife at all?

I know faith should cover these aspects of uncertainty but you have to live for the present life. If you don't, you will make yourself unhappy for as long as you live because you will always be looking forward to the next life. If there is no next life, you will have looked forward to absolutely nothing.

Please listen to us when we say 'Enjoy your life and live it to the best of your ability'.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 01/29/04 at 08:44 a.m.

Quoting:
Andrew,

it doesn't seem like you read Absolutely Vile's most excellent post. It's a shame because you should. Vile makes excellent points in reference to this subject.
End Quote



Thank you! I try...:D

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 01/29/04 at 11:29 a.m.

For those of You who take Psychiatric Drugs, what do you do if your shrink, suggests or tries to put you on a different medication against your will.
My opinion is that the Patient should have the final say.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: 80s_cheerleader on 01/29/04 at 11:47 a.m.


Quoting:
For those of You who take Psychiatric Drugs, what do you do if your shrink, suggests or tries to put you on a different medication against your will.
My opinion is that the Patient should have the final say.
End Quote



You DO have the final say.  The doctor can't make you do anything you don't want to do (unless you're locked up in a psychiatric hospital).  I don't know what kind of doctors you see, but all of them that my grandmother saw said that the choice was hers whether she wanted medication or not.  If you don't agree with a doctor's evaluation, you always have the ability to get a second opinion or just walk out the door.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 01/29/04 at 12:02 a.m.

Question for Howard:
You said that you had OCD, and that you used to take Medication for it,
I was under the impression that OCD is a chronic condition, plus many people with OCD, have crippling Depression as a secondary symptom.
Which might cause it to be MisDiagnosed as Depression.
So how did you overcome it.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 01/29/04 at 12:14 a.m.

Quoting:
It's High time that Disability Advocates take on the Social Security Administration,
More Money,and Services should be given to the Disabled.
End Quote



What's this got to do with the mentally ill? I'm speaking as both mentally ill and physically disabled. You've gone from one subject to another. I think you're just confusing me and everyone else. Are you saying mentally ill people are disabled? There's a difference between a mental illness and a mental disability. A mental illness is usually emotional or behavioural. A mental disability is usually cognitive, meaning these people have difficulty learning and grasping the basic knowledge that one needs to go through life. Sometimes a mental illness and mental disability can go hand-in-hand, since a lot of times someone with a mental disability gets frustrated because of his or her limitations. (By the way, since I only have a mental illness and not a mental disability, this is only my perspective of life with a mental disability. It's somewhat similiar to what I go through with a physical disability.)

Incidentally, Andrew...am I just wasting my typing skills? Do you actually read or acknowledge other people's posts, or do you just answer your own and spout off inane questions and comments? You really should read what other people have to say on the subject you started.

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 01/29/04 at 12:22 a.m.

Quoting:


You DO have the final say.  The doctor can't make you do anything you don't want to do (unless you're locked up in a psychiatric hospital).  I don't know what kind of doctors you see, but all of them that my grandmother saw said that the choice was hers whether she wanted medication or not.  If you don't agree with a doctor's evaluation, you always have the ability to get a second opinion or just walk out the door.
End Quote



I totally agree. Doctors or psychiatrists who force you into a treatment you don't agree with shouldn't even be in their profession. I've always been given a choice, but I'm also open to any suggestion my doctor has given me as to what medication to take. (Although lately, she's gotten totally the wrong impression about my depression and anxiety that I won't even bother talking to her about it anymore.)

Do you really have no say in your treatment if you're in a mental hospital? I would think that even that would be unethical.

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 01/29/04 at 06:25 p.m.


Quoting:
Question for Howard:
You said that you had OCD, and that you used to take Medication for it,
I was under the impression that OCD is a chronic condition, plus many people with OCD, have crippling Depression as a secondary symptom.
Which might cause it to be MisDiagnosed as Depression.
So how did you overcome it.
End Quote



My Mother and My psychiatrist in July 1999,said I felt and looked much better.It was something in my brain. :(

Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 01/30/04 at 03:26 a.m.

Quoting:
Incidentally, Andrew...am I just wasting my typing skills? Do you actually read or acknowledge other people's posts, or do you just answer your own and spout off inane questions and comments? You really should read what other people have to say on the subject you started.

Absolutely Vile
End Quote



Indeed. I've mentioned it previously . . .  ::)

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: 80s_cheerleader on 01/30/04 at 06:14 a.m.

Quoting:

Do you really have no say in your treatment if you're in a mental hospital? I would think that even that would be unethical.

Absolutely Vile
End Quote


I had a friend who was in a mental hospital for a short time.  She was unable to assist in her treatment initially.  For quite a while, the doctors kept trying different medications until they found a combination that worked.  From what she's told me, most of the people in there were unable to help in their treatment plans.  Their problems were so severe, they had no idea what was going on, or they were being overmedicated.  

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 01/30/04 at 10:41 a.m.

I'm just glad I wasn't put in a mental hospital for anything. :)

Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 02/01/04 at 01:42 p.m.

We must of course realize, that their is more than one way to "Be a Productive member of Society" than working at a Job.
Look at Stephen Hawking, the Brilliant Physicist, he's disabled, yet he is a Productive member of Society, by writing his books, and by being an inspiration to others, in fact a Star Trek magazine called him a "Hero" I agree, he is a Hero to all humanity.

Not all Disabled persons, are equally disabled or disabled to the same extent, just like Not all Non-Disabled Persons, are equal in ability.
I've always said the Social Security Administration should give more money and services to the disabled with less paperwork,
I wish no human being had to suffer a mental or physical condintion, it pains me to see human suffering, and poverty.
 

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: LyricBoy on 02/01/04 at 01:47 p.m.

Andrew you raise a very good point.

The worth of an individual can not be simply measured by conventional means.  Those with different abilities can excel in different ways, like you mentioned with Steven Hawking.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 02/01/04 at 01:49 p.m.

And look at it this way,
If nobody became disabled, it would mean that people whose Job it is to work for Social Security for Disability Claims(they would be out of the Job)
I guess you could argue, everything, good or bad happens for a Reason.
 I hope we all get what we want in life.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Mordor on 02/02/04 at 00:00 a.m.

To me,anything that further enables the mentally ill to live a better life is great.
We need all the help we can get sometimes:)
but,IMO,its wrong to try to make others do things you wouldnt do or dont like for various reasons.
If you've never been at the last breath before you try to commit suicide,youll never know what it feels like.I lived,but sometimes I wish I didnt.I wouldnt know if I missed life-i'd be dead! ::)That was looooooong ago and I wasnt on any medication and drank like a fish.C'est la vie! ;D

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 02/02/04 at 06:05 a.m.

Quoting:
And look at it this way,
If nobody became disabled, it would mean that people whose Job it is to work for Social Security for Disability Claims(they would be out of the Job)
I guess you could argue, everything, good or bad happens for a Reason.
 I hope we all get what we want in life.
End Quote



That's right. It's almost a form of Chaos theory were everybody's lives are very much affected by each other. Without the need for computers (which is entirely false), Bill Gates would be down the Jobcentre by now.  ;D

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: 80s_cheerleader on 02/02/04 at 01:16 p.m.


Quoting:
.
I've always said the Social Security Administration should give more money and services to the disabled with less paperwork,
End Quote



Sorry, I have to disagree with this statement.  There are too many people taking advantage of the disability system in this country.  Personally, I know of 3 who are on disability for "anxiety" disorders who are perfectly capable of holding down a job, in fact, 1 of them works under the table (for cash), but have no desire to do so.  The 1 who does hold a job works at a restaurant where she basically comes and goes as she pleases.  And, since she's having an affair with the owner, he lets her.  So, for the time she's physically there, he pays her $6/hour.  Granted, she's not working most of the time, just pouring coffee and wiping the counter, but she makes more than any other employee there.  Now, for those who have been physically or mentally disabled since birth, I agree with your statement.  Hubby's cousin has severe Down's Syndrome.  However, in order for her parents to receive her disability benefits, she has to be reevaluated every year or so to make sure she is still disabled.  THAT, I think is ridiculous.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 02/02/04 at 02:01 p.m.

Quoting:
Now, for those who have been physically or mentally disabled since birth, I agree with your statement.  Hubby's cousin has severe Down's Syndrome.  However, in order for her parents to receive her disability benefits, she has to be reevaluated every year or so to make sure she is still disabled.  THAT, I think is ridiculous.
End Quote



It's the same with me. I'm on Social Assistance (or I think they call it "Employment and Income Assistance"), and in order to renew my health benefits (optician, dentist, prescriptions), they send me these forms for me and my doctor (who now charges for filling out forms) to complete to verify that I'm still physically handicapped (like I have been for 31 years), when nothing's going to change, and they know that!! I even have to do the same thing for my handicapped parking pass!! It's stupid!

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: CurtisLowe on 02/02/04 at 02:10 p.m.

I think anyone anywhere ought to have the right to kill themselves if they don't want to be a part of this world for any reason. Antiquaited religious notions have no part in a persons freedom unless they desire them too.

More on topic, I agree that to many doctors are prescribing too many pills, many of wich future side effects aren't even known. Even worse the amount of children that are prescribed on such drugs is staggering. I also suffer from anxiety and deppression issues, but after two years they finally figured out what I told them in the first place, that it's my issues with society that cause these problems, and none of the psych drugs they put me on did anything to solve that problem, and only made me worse. The Mental Health industry has simply too many psyhiatrists (sp?)  that have their own theories about what medicines will work well and wich won't, and many of these medicines end up being harmful to the patient. I take Librium now, wich is basically the first from of Valium, but much less addictive. It helps me get thru my anger when I look out and see all the harm that people do to one another.

"When you're little, you like to think you know everything, but the last thing you really want is to know too much. What you really want is for grown-ups to make the world a safe place where dreams can come true and promises are never broken. And when you're little, it doesn't seem like a lot to ask. "  Allie from the series Taken

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 02/02/04 at 03:35 p.m.

I appreciate your anger, Curtis. I used to have a bad attitude caused by the thinking that 'If I see that something is wrong then it is unfair and therefore intolerable' - This caused a lot of anger.

I'm glad that you are getting help for this.  :)

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 02/02/04 at 03:42 p.m.

Vile, how did you become handicapped? Is it something from birth or a gradual thing? If you mentioned this in previous posts then I apologise in advance . . .

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 02/02/04 at 03:55 p.m.

Quoting:
Vile, how did you become handicapped? Is it something from birth or a gradual thing? If you mentioned this in previous posts then I apologise in advance . . .
End Quote



I was born with Spina Bifida, and am paralysed from the waist down. What irks me the most is this could have been prevented by eating a proper diet with plenty of folic acid.

I've also got scoliosis and hydrocephalus, I think (which has something to do with fluid going to the brain so I've got a shunt in my head to keep it from going up there).

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 02/02/04 at 04:08 p.m.

Quoting:
I was born with Spina Bifida, and am paralysed from the waist down. What irks me the most is this could have been prevented by eating a proper diet with plenty of folic acid.

I've also got scoliosis and hydrocephalus, I think (which has something to do with fluid going to the brain so I've got a shunt in my head to keep it from going up there).
End Quote



You know, it is posts like this that put it all in perspective for me. Over the weekend, I was worried because I have a receeding hair-line and the hairdresser said that I should have my head shaved! That is all I have to physically worry about! I should be grateful.

Thank you for your post.  :)

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 02/02/04 at 05:26 p.m.

Quoting:


You know, it is posts like this that put it all in perspective for me. Over the weekend, I was worried because I have a receeding hair-line and the hairdresser said that I should have my head shaved! That is all I have to physically worry about! I should be grateful.

Thank you for your post.  :)
End Quote



Oh, don't worry about it. You're welcome! :D It's just something I have to put up with, I guess. I have no choice. Yes, I get depressed and anxious a lot (which is why I've been trying to find some sort of help), but I have a wonderful husband, four adorable Guinea Pigs, Depeche Mode and Morrissey. What else could a girl ask for? :) They all bring me happiness and that's what keeps me on this earth. I've put up with a lot of sh*t from people, especially when I was school, but I've always had something to turn to. Usually music. I locked myself up in my bedroom a lot. Now, as an adult, I'm just looking for people who can look past the wheelchair and see that I have many talents and abilities, and should be taken seriously! I'm beginning to lose hope though. I've been told so many times that I have limitations and that I should be realistic in what I want to do in life, that I've begun to believe it and have only been in mediocre, mundane jobs like telemarketing. I lack the confidence to do anything I want to do. I need to reprogram my brain to think a little higher of myself. Anyway...I'm sorry. I'm waffling.

About your hair: Maybe you'd look good with a bald head! Whatever you do, though, don't go for a comb-over!!! That's hideous! :)

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 02/02/04 at 06:41 p.m.

My Mother thought that after I was born that I grew up to have seizures,But she was wrong only Water On The Brain. :(

Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: LyricBoy on 02/02/04 at 07:14 p.m.


Quoting:

About your hair: Maybe you'd look good with a bald head! Whatever you do, though, don't go for a comb-over!!! That's hideous! :)

Absolutely Vile
End Quote



Even worse than the dreaded comb-over is the Swirly or Swirl-Over.  That's where you grow this one, really long lock of hair, then "swirl" it over the top of your head so that "nobody" knows that you are bald.  8)

I had a boss with one of those swirlies, and it was ridiculous looking.  He would have looked MUCH BETTER if he had just been naturally bald.  His swirly had 2.5 "rotations" (we counted).  :P

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: CurtisLowe on 02/03/04 at 00:03 a.m.


Quoting:
I appreciate your anger, Curtis. I used to have a bad attitude caused by the thinking that 'If I see that something is wrong then it is unfair and therefore intolerable' - This caused a lot of anger.

I'm glad that you are getting help for this.  :)
End Quote



Thanx. Sometimes tho I think that coming to message boards doesn't help my condition any ;)  .  But it helps a great deal in coping skills.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 02/03/04 at 04:15 a.m.

Quoting:
I'm beginning to lose hope though. I've been told so many times that I have limitations and that I should be realistic in what I want to do in life, that I've begun to believe it and have only been in mediocre, mundane jobs like telemarketing. I lack the confidence to do anything I want to do. I need to reprogram my brain to think a little higher of myself. Anyway...I'm sorry. I'm waffling.

About your hair: Maybe you'd look good with a bald head! Whatever you do, though, don't go for a comb-over!!! That's hideous! :)
End Quote



Know that you are valuable and you will become valuable. I don't know if I'm quoting someone but it is absolutely true. A lot of people stay in the positions they are in life because they don't know if they can do better (I'm included).

The evidence I see on this board is that you are an intelligent, thoughtful person and, wheelchair or not, that doesn't deter from the fact.

As for my hair, I said to my girlfriend "That's it, if it gets any worse, it's coming off!". No comb-overs for me! My grandad was completely bald and he looked quite good so there might be some hope yet for me - However, this is a totally different subject altogether . . .

There is one thing you have affected in me and that is I listen to The Smiths a bit more these days.  ;D

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 02/03/04 at 08:37 a.m.

Quoting:
The evidence I see on this board is that you are an intelligent, thoughtful person and, wheelchair or not, that doesn't deter from the fact.End Quote



Thank you. :) I try not to be a complete idiot on here. :)

Quoting:There is one thing you have affected in me and that is I listen to The Smiths a bit more these days.  ;D
End Quote



The power of Vile compels you! The power of Vile compels you! ;D

I have that influence on people, it seems. When I met my husband (on the 'net!), he was depressed, and I told him to start listening to The Smiths, because Morrissey's words had certainly helped me. So he went and bought their albums, and he became a fan! I was so pleased. :) I don't know if he's as obsessed with them as I am, but he really likes them, and he has me to thank! ...And so do you, I guess. :)

My hubby has paid me back though. I've become a bigger Mode fan (Depeche Mode, that is) because of him. I've always liked them, but now I really love them!! ;D Same with Radiohead. And he's made me "appreciate" Oasis. I couldn't stand them before. :)

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 02/03/04 at 06:04 p.m.


Quoting:


Even worse than the dreaded comb-over is the Swirly or Swirl-Over.  That's where you grow this one, really long lock of hair, then "swirl" it over the top of your head so that "nobody" knows that you are bald.  8)

I had a boss with one of those swirlies, and it was ridiculous looking.  He would have looked MUCH BETTER if he had just been naturally bald.  His swirly had 2.5 "rotations" (we counted).  :P
End Quote




As for me LB,I'm halfway bald.It runs in the Family! :P


Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 02/04/04 at 08:22 a.m.

In the past in America, before the invention of Psychiatric Drugs, they made people with Chronic Severe Mental illness live AGAINST THEIR WILL, in terrible emotional pain, Such evil which existed back then, Heaven Forbid, those people would commit suicide without Physically hurting anyone else, Oh no, the horror.
Today, it's not much better, people are forced to live dependant upon Psychiatric Drugs.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 02/04/04 at 04:07 p.m.

Quoting:
The power of Vile compels you! The power of Vile compels you! ;DEnd Quote



Indeed it does. I like Frankly Mr Shankly and Bigmouth strikes again. You will have a hard job compelling me to like Oasis though . . .  :)

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 02/04/04 at 04:12 p.m.

Quoting:
In the past in America, before the invention of Psychiatric Drugs, they made people with Chronic Severe Mental illness live AGAINST THEIR WILL, in terrible emotional pain, Such evil which existed back then, Heaven Forbid, those people would commit suicide without Physically hurting anyone else, Oh no, the horror.
Today, it's not much better, people are forced to live dependant upon Psychiatric Drugs.
End Quote



Yes but aren't doctors binded by something called The Hippocratic Oath? This means that they have to care for the patients and keep them alive as much as they can. So even though people in the past were in agonising pain, it was, as it still is, the doctor's main duty to keep patients alive.

Click for the Hippocratic oath:

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/doctors/oath_classical.html

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 02/04/04 at 04:27 p.m.

Quoting:


Indeed it does. I like Frankly Mr Shankly and Bigmouth strikes again. You will have a hard job compelling me to like Oasis though . . .  :)


End Quote



Oh that's OK. I don't mind. As I said, I just "appreciate" them, or tolerate them. I don't hate them anymore.

I will claim victory if I get you to like "Meat Is Murder." :D

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: CurtisLowe on 02/04/04 at 04:35 p.m.


Quoting:

Today, it's not much better, people are forced to live dependant upon Psychiatric Drugs.
End Quote



That's a good point. I've heard people argue that people have the choice to refuse medication, but in the confused state we find ourselves in, how are we to know but to trust that the doctor knows what he is doing? A lesson I found out over too many years and too many misdiagnoses'. It wasn't until two YEARS that a therapist told me I had the right to suggest what medicines I felt would help me . After nuch research into effects and causes and uses of this or that particular medicine.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 02/04/04 at 04:37 p.m.

Quoting:
I will claim victory if I get you to like "Meat Is Murder." :D
End Quote



Ho ho! I smell a challenge! I will have a listen to it for that!  ;D

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 02/04/04 at 05:12 p.m.

Quoting:


Ho ho! I smell a challenge! I will have a listen to it for that!  ;D
End Quote



Excellent! And by the way...I mean the song, not the album. :) I just want to know what sort of effect it will have. ;)

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 02/05/04 at 06:12 p.m.

I used to take medication. :(



Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 02/06/04 at 08:23 a.m.

Personally, I don't think society shout stigmatize Suicide, or people who have commited suicide,
Any human being no matter how stable or well off, would take his or her own life. We all have our limits.
People with chronic mental disorders and illness, those whose life is the most difficult are in my opinion being UNJUSTLY DEPRIVED of their Right to commit suicide without physically hurting anyone else.  It pains me to see suffering in this world, Personally I believe that the President instead of wasting Government money on the insane war with Iraq or wasting more Billions on the space program, he should use the Money to CURE and eliminate all chronic Mental and Physical conditions, Not just treat them.

The sad thing is that in New York City/New York State, many Mental Health Professionals are Jewish, and this generates a VERY rabid anti-Jewish backlash. some have claimed the Mental Health Profession is "Jewish Dominated" or that a Disproportionate number of Mental Health Professionals are Jewish.

Sorry if this offends anyone.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: LyricBoy on 02/06/04 at 08:58 a.m.

Somehow I don't think that people who are mentally ill are avoiding their medical professional because she or he is Jewish.  And because there appears to be so many jewish people in these professions, it would not seem like they are being overly oppressed or discriminated against.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 02/08/04 at 04:27 p.m.

Yes, but a disturbing notion I once read, is that those who commit suicide due to a severe Mental disorder or illness, that those people are made by God to Reincarnate and Relive their Mental illness Nightmare all over again??
Such Horror,
The God I worship would allow those suicides to still go to Heaven, and Not make them reincarnate and Relive their entire Hellish Nightmare lives due to mental illness all over again?
In other words I would pray their would be no Negative Consequences for them

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 02/08/04 at 04:32 p.m.

know what people with mental illnesses do? They kill people such as Janice Brucia,committ suicide,shoot,stab,pedophile,and the list goes on and on.... ::) >:(


Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 02/08/04 at 05:05 p.m.

Quoting:
know what people with mental illnesses do? They kill people such as Janice Brucia,committ suicide,shoot,stab,pedophile,and the list goes on and on.... ::) >:(


Howard
End Quote



I don't!! Do you? I don't know any mentally ill people that would even consider murdering someone or committing any sort of heinous crime.

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 02/08/04 at 05:40 p.m.

I understand what Howard is saying but I have suffered mental illness and believe me, killing people was the last thing on my mind.  ;)

Even the really mentally ill people (paranoid schizophrenic especially) probably kill or injure people as a consequence of their illness/train of thinking brought on by that illness. If someone thinks that somebody is out to get them, I guess the first thing someone does is protect themselves. Mentally ill people are just that - ill. They are not well. Some maybe dangerous but I believe that of sane people as well.

Where did you read that from, Andrew? God is supposed to be a God of love. He certainly isn't showing love by making a perfectly innocent person relive their whole mental traumas again.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 02/09/04 at 05:27 a.m.

I apologize from what I said the other day. maybe I was just jumping to conclusions.I forgot to think of what I was going to say.Sorry,Vile and Bobby! :-[


Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 02/09/04 at 08:43 a.m.


Quoting:
I apologize from what I said the other day. maybe I was just jumping to conclusions.I forgot to think of what I was going to say.Sorry,Vile and Bobby! :-everybody who has a mental illness exhibits criminal behaviour!! :D

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 02/09/04 at 06:15 p.m.


Quoting:


It's OK. I was just kind of surprised that you, who I believe also has a mental illness (OCD), would say such a thing. Not everybody who has a mental illness exhibits criminal behaviour!! :D

Absolutely Vile
End Quote



Hey,Hey,Hey,I don't like to be called "mental" or have a mental illness. just doesn't sound right with me..just say learning disability! ;)feels much better. ;D


Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 02/09/04 at 10:49 p.m.


Quoting:


Hey,Hey,Hey,I don't like to be called "mental" or have a mental illness. just doesn't sound right with me..just say learning disability! ;)feels much better. ;D


Howard
End Quote



I never called you mental! But OK...I didn't think someone with a learning disability would say something like that.  ;D ;)

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 02/10/04 at 04:34 a.m.

Quoting:
I apologize from what I said the other day. maybe I was just jumping to conclusions.I forgot to think of what I was going to say.Sorry,Vile and Bobby! :-[End Quote



That's O.k Howard. I sort of understood why you said what you said.  :)

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 02/10/04 at 06:09 p.m.


Quoting:


I never called you mental! But OK...I didn't think someone with a learning disability would say something like that.  ;D ;)

Absolutely Vile
End Quote



I'm sorry V,I guess that being surrounded with people with mental illnesses for the past 13 years made me think.But using the words such as Crazy,Psychiatric,Rehab & moron when saying it to a person with that kind puts someone down.I apologize if you were offended. :-[

Were all in the same boat together. :)

Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 02/10/04 at 06:10 p.m.


Quoting:


That's O.k Howard. I sort of understood why you said what you said.  :)
End Quote




Thanks Bob. :)


Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 02/10/04 at 10:49 p.m.


Quoting:


I'm sorry V,I guess that being surrounded with people with mental illnesses for the past 13 years made me think.But using the words such as Crazy,Psychiatric,Rehab & moron when saying it to a person with that kind puts someone down.I apologize if you were offended. :-am and I accept it! :D You do have to have a sense of humour about certain things, and I try to have one. If I ever get offended by something petty, I'm probably depressed, or anxious, or just miserable. I don't mind little labels, but if someone attacks my character, that's when I really get angry. I wouldn't do that to anyone else, so no one should do that to me.

Yes we should all stick together, and support each other!! Sometimes the only person a mentally ill person will understand is another mentally ill person. Personally, I hate opening up to upbeat, "life is super!" people. Especially when I'm really depressed. They make me want to vomit. :P

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 02/11/04 at 05:55 a.m.

Quoting:
Yes we should all stick together, and support each other!! Sometimes the only person a mentally ill person will understand is another mentally ill person. Personally, I hate opening up to upbeat, "life is super!" people. Especially when I'm really depressed. They make me want to vomit. :P
End Quote



I understand, Vile. When I was depressed, I heard a lot of people go on about how great life is but you have to see that for yourself. Having someone tell me that life is great at that time is like someone telling me you can't eat cakes while you are trying to diet - No help at all  :-/.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 02/11/04 at 08:48 a.m.

Yes, but some have said that God, when those with severe mental disorders/illness commit suicide, God makes them Re-live their entire Hellish Mental illness life all over again?
Isn't Once Enough, can't those that take their own life have the Peace in Death they couldn't find in real life?
Could their be No Negative Consequences?

I mean, the famous painter Vincent Van Gogh, would God make him Re-live his Mental illness nightmare because he commited suicide

Or Michael J. Fox, would God make him Re-Live his entire Parkinson's Nightmare all over again?

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 02/11/04 at 08:51 a.m.

 Mental Health Professionals in the United States and Worldwide, should Realize they are part of an EVIL Legacy

Before the 1940's, and 50's when the First Psychiatric drugs were created, these Mental Health Professionals, forced the Mentally ill to live Against their will, without any Psychiatric Drugs, such evil

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 02/11/04 at 09:43 a.m.

    Every time I see Animal Rights fanatics, I feel like saying to them, they should focus more on Rights of the Mentally ill,
I mean I support limited animal rights, and animals killed for food or clothing should be killed in a Quick and Humane way.
But these "PETA" groups take it too an extreme

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: 80s_cheerleader on 02/11/04 at 09:59 a.m.


Quoting:
 Mental Health Professionals in the United States and Worldwide, should Realize they are part of an EVIL Legacy

Before the 1940's, and 50's when the First Psychiatric drugs were created, these Mental Health Professionals, forced the Mentally ill to live Against their will, without any Psychiatric Drugs, such evil
End Quote



Okay, so people should not be forced to take the psych. drugs, but the MHP's were "evil" for not giving them?  You need to make up your mind.  Oh, and how were the MHP's supposed to give these people the drugs if they weren't even invented yet? ::)

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: LyricBoy on 02/11/04 at 10:57 a.m.

Quoting:
Yes, but some have said that God, when those with severe mental disorders/illness commit suicide, God makes them Re-live their entire Hellish Mental illness life all over again?
Isn't Once Enough, can't those that take their own life have the Peace in Death they couldn't find in real life?

Could their be No Negative Consequences?
End Quote



Andrew, who ON EARTH told you that God does this?  Because unless it was God, they do not know what He would do.

Personally, as a mortal who does not claim to "know" what God will do, I suspect that He would only be upset with me if I wasted the talents that He gave me.  

I feel that if I use my God-given talents, however small or insignificant they may seem, to help other people, I'll do OK in the Afterlife.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 02/11/04 at 03:25 p.m.

Quoting:
Yes, but some have said that God, when those with severe mental disorders/illness commit suicide, God makes them Re-live their entire Hellish Mental illness life all over again?
Isn't Once Enough, can't those that take their own life have the Peace in Death they couldn't find in real life?
Could their be No Negative Consequences?

I mean, the famous painter Vincent Van Gogh, would God make him Re-live his Mental illness nightmare because he commited suicide

Or Michael J. Fox, would God make him Re-Live his entire Parkinson's Nightmare all over again?
End Quote



What do you think?

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 02/11/04 at 06:08 p.m.


Quoting:


I wasn't offended!! Don't worry! I'm very rarely offended. I don't mind being called crazy...insane...moron...cripple...because I am and I accept it! :D You do have to have a sense of humour about certain things, and I try to have one. If I ever get offended by something petty, I'm probably depressed, or anxious, or just miserable. I don't mind little labels, but if someone attacks my character, that's when I really get angry. I wouldn't do that to anyone else, so no one should do that to me.

Yes we should all stick together, and support each other!! Sometimes the only person a mentally ill person will understand is another mentally ill person. Personally, I hate opening up to upbeat, "life is super!" people. Especially when I'm really depressed. They make me want to vomit. :P

Absolutely Vile
End Quote




That's great! I'm glad you understand :). anyways,you by any chance get SSI in the mail for your disability benefits? I've been on SSI for about almost 9 years now but I want to work but I'm gonna have to start from the beginning and volunteer like I used to do in the past.I haven't had a good paying job in 10 years so I'm gonna have to start somewhere.That sucks,But I have no choice right now.Who knows how long I'm gonna be on disability benefits! :-/ :(

Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 02/11/04 at 07:04 p.m.


Quoting:



That's great! I'm glad you understand :). anyways,you by any chance get SSI in the mail for your disability benefits? I've been on SSI for about almost 9 years now but I want to work but I'm gonna have to start from the beginning and volunteer like I used to do in the past.I haven't had a good paying job in 10 years so I'm gonna have to start somewhere.That sucks,But I have no choice right now.Who knows how long I'm gonna be on disability benefits! :-/ :(

Howard
End Quote



I don't live in the States (I'm in Canada), so no. I'm on Employment & Income Assistance, which is basically welfare because everybody unemployed can collect it. You get a monthly cheque (or apparently people can get it every two weeks. I'll have to look into that and make sure that's just not for the Natives.) If you're working, you have to fill out forms to tell them how much you made each month, and if it's under their cutoff (basically less than what they give you), they'll supplement your income and give you a bit of extra money. If you're handicapped and working, you get an extra 80 bucks for work incentive. So basically...as I've found anyway...you're no better off working than you are on welfare unless you have a really good paying job, which I have never had. You CAN get disability benefits, but that's a completely different thing altogether, and it's for handicapped people who can't work at all. I wouldn't qualify.

By the way...I'm only speaking for the province I live in. I don't know what sort of assistance disabled people in the other provinces get. I've never lived anywhere else.

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 02/12/04 at 05:42 p.m.

The time has come for Medical Science to Eliminate Mental illness and Disorders once and for all,
to merely treat them is Not enough, to keep people dependant upon Psychiatric Drugs for Decades is not the answer,
Mental Disorders and illnesses, must be CURED, Once and For all.
Their must be a way to Permanently and 100percent correct the chemical imbalances.
Yet, our President wastes Government money on the Space Program????

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 02/12/04 at 05:45 p.m.

Let's NOT forget the

5 points that I originally made.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 02/13/04 at 05:59 a.m.


Quoting:


I don't live in the States (I'm in Canada), so no. I'm on Employment & Income Assistance, which is basically welfare because everybody unemployed can collect it. You get a monthly cheque (or apparently people can get it every two weeks. I'll have to look into that and make sure that's just not for the Natives.) If you're working, you have to fill out forms to tell them how much you made each month, and if it's under their cutoff (basically less than what they give you), they'll supplement your income and give you a bit of extra money. If you're handicapped and working, you get an extra 80 bucks for work incentive. So basically...as I've found anyway...you're no better off working than you are on welfare unless you have a really good paying job, which I have never had. You CAN get disability benefits, but that's a completely different thing altogether, and it's for handicapped people who can't work at all. I wouldn't qualify.

By the way...I'm only speaking for the province I live in. I don't know what sort of assistance disabled people in the other provinces get. I've never lived anywhere else.

Absolutely Vile
End Quote



If I was never on SSI,I would've been at my paying job at Genovese by now 11 years.But,I know you can't change the past.I blame my being fired on my damn compulsion. >:( :-/


Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 02/13/04 at 08:55 a.m.

For all those people who in the past commited suicide due to a Mental disorder or illness, I pray God forgave them. And that they are still in Heaven.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 02/13/04 at 09:05 a.m.

I am not the first person to say, that I think it's barbaric and unjust for the Mental Health Profession to expect people to live for Decades on End, Dependant upon Psychiatric drugs, I mean that's obscene.

Who are they to Force anyone to live Against their will? When they prevent those with chronic Mental disorders and illness from killing themselves without Physically hurting anyone else, they are the Enemies of the Mentally ill

Their should be a Million Mental Illness March, a March for people with chronic Mental Disorders/illness  to take their own lives.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 02/13/04 at 09:07 a.m.

I mean Chronic Mental illness, can make life as Unbearable as a Terminal illness.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 02/13/04 at 09:20 a.m.

Is America Truly a "Free" country. The answer is NO!!!
You can blame the Puritans for that, if you want my opinion, their are 3 Vital changes that should occur in America

1.Ending the insane "War on Drugs" and Vice Squads
2.Legalizing and Regulating Prostitution,
3.Legalizing the Right to Die,

www.libertocracy.com

And back to the Rights of the Mentally ill, if YOU had a chronic Mental disorder or illness, would YOU want the Government or Mental Health Profession to Force you to live Dependant upon Psychiatric drugs.

I must admit, the articles on that website have alot of emotion to them, as Scary as it is
MANY Americans, Agree with Timothy McVeigh's view about the Government, about it being abusive and Fascist,
Of Course, the deplore his heartless Terrorism, and violence, that's not the answer,
But the Netherlands, is truly an Example of what America should be like,

The ONLY way to change America, and make it into a Truly free country like the Netherlands, is for all citizens to organize a MASSIVE Peacful Law-Abiding Reform effort.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: LyricBoy on 02/13/04 at 09:37 a.m.


Quoting:
Is America Truly a "Free" country. The answer is NO!!!
You can blame the Puritans for that, if you want my opinion, their are 3 Vital changes that should occur in America

1.Ending the insane "War on Drugs" and Vice Squads
2.Legalizing and Regulating Prostitution,
3.Legalizing the Right to Die,

And back to the Rights of the Mentally ill, if YOU had a chronic Mental disorder or illness, would YOU want the Government or Mental Health Profession to Force you to live Dependant upon Psychiatric drugs.End Quote



Is somebody forcing you to take drugs?  Does somebody you know want to die, but isn't doing it because it is illegal?

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: 80s_cheerleader on 02/13/04 at 10:13 a.m.


Quoting:
I am not the first person to say, that I think it's barbaric and unjust for the Mental Health Profession to expect people to live for Decades on End, Dependant upon Psychiatric drugs, I mean that's obscene.

Who are they to Force anyone to live Against their will? When they prevent those with chronic Mental disorders and illness from killing themselves without Physically hurting anyone else, they are the Enemies of the Mentally ill

Their should be a Million Mental Illness March, a March for people with chronic Mental Disorders/illness  to take their own lives.
End Quote



Except for those who are involuntarily institutionalized, ANYONE, mentally ill or not, can take their life.  You may not believe it, but MOST people who have some type of mental illness/disability DO NOT want to end their life.  Sure, they wish for a cure, but until that time, they must live their life on the drugs.  My grandmother was mentally ill, but lived a relatively normal life, thanks to various medications.  She didn't HAVE to take the medication, she did so because she WANTED to live her life, to see her grandchildren & great grandchildren grow up.  She could have stopped the medication or killed herself any time she wanted.  She didn't want to.  For you to assume that everyone who is ill WANTS to commit suicide is wrong.  If someone really wants to do it, they will find a way.  Noone can stop them.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: 80s_cheerleader on 02/13/04 at 10:18 a.m.


Quoting:
The time has come for Medical Science to Eliminate Mental illness and Disorders once and for all,
to merely treat them is Not enough, to keep people dependant upon Psychiatric Drugs for Decades is not the answer,
Mental Disorders and illnesses, must be CURED, Once and For all.
Their must be a way to Permanently and 100percent correct the chemical imbalances.

End Quote



Sorry, I think there are more deadly diseases out there to cure:  diabetes, cancer, AIDS, MS, cerebral palsy, among a host of others. ::)

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 02/13/04 at 12:17 a.m.

Andrew...

No one in the mental health field forces anyone to do anything anymore, although I've never been institutionalised so I don't know what goes on in there. In the first half of the twentieth century, up until around 1960 when the first psychiatric drugs came to surface, people were forced to endure all sorts of barbaric experiments, from the inhumane use of electro-shock treatment with no sedatives to the infamous "ice pick lobotomies," whereby a doctor would stick an ice pick through your eyelid to the frontal lobe of your brain and sever the connection between the frontal lobe and the rest of your brain, leaving you in a catatonic state. And that is, if they didn't just chain you up in a padded cell. I won't even go into the mediaeval treatments that came before then. I'm sorry, but I think I'd rather be on anti-depressants than go through all that. If mentally ill people only had the choice between barbaric experimental treatments and suicide, then maybe I could see your point. But since effective medications do exist, that gives someone living with a mental illness that extra bit of hope for a normal existence. I think they would prefer the option of life with the help of something to keep them normal, to the finality of death. I would, anyway.

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: 80s_cheerleader on 02/13/04 at 12:20 a.m.


Quoting:
Andrew...

No one in the mental health field forces anyone to do anything anymore, although I've never been institutionalised so I don't know what goes on in there. In the first half of the twentieth century, up until around 1960 when the first psychiatric drugs came to surface, people were forced to endure all sorts of barbaric experiments, from the inhumane use of electro-shock treatment with no sedatives to the infamous "ice pick lobotomies," whereby a doctor would stick an ice pick through your eyelid to the frontal lobe of your brain and sever the connection between the frontal lobe and the rest of your brain, leaving you in a catatonic state. And that is, if they didn't just chain you up in a padded cell. I won't even go into the mediaeval treatments that came before then. I'm sorry, but I think I'd rather be on anti-depressants than go through all that. If mentally ill people only had the choice between barbaric experimental treatments and suicide, then maybe I could see your point. But since effective medications do exist, that gives someone living with a mental illness that extra bit of hope for a normal existence. I think they would prefer the option of life with the help of something to keep them normal, to the finality of death. I would, anyway.

Absolutely Vile
End Quote



Applause to you.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Snowcrystal on 02/13/04 at 12:24 a.m.

People with certain mental illnesses have to take medication, otherwise they would be a danger to themselves or others.
These are people with illnesses that they were born with, like a handicap. They can't control themselves without it.
Now as for depression, anxiety, addiction, etc., meds are just a tool (suppose to be, atleast) to help them So they can help themselves by going through therapy and everything they need to do to get better.
It's a booster.
But if they don't bother doing any work, they don't get better, they just depend on the meds.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 02/13/04 at 12:37 a.m.


Quoting:
People with certain mental illnesses have to take medication, otherwise they would be a danger to themselves or others.
These are people with illnesses that they were born with, like a handicap. They can't control themselves without it.
Now as for depression, anxiety, addiction, etc., meds are just a tool (suppose to be, atleast) to help them So they can help themselves by going through therapy and everything they need to do to get better.
It's a booster.
But if they don't bother doing any work, they don't get better, they just depend on the meds.

End Quote



That's true as well. Medications are just a bandage, really. It's one thing to take medications; they make you "feel happier." But to really get down to the root of the problem(s), a good therapist/psychiatrist is the key. Although I've still yet to find out how one can talk about their problems while on "happy pills," I suppose both work consecutively. You just need to find a pill that balances your emotions out more than just make you happy and giddy...which has been my experience so far, if they didn't make me sleepy.

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Snowcrystal on 02/13/04 at 01:02 p.m.

I myself used antidepressants for a while but found myself doing a lot better without it, because of that, feeling like I don't need to get my butt out there and make myself better.
Ended up getting off of it and dealing with my intense feelings, depression and anxiety,  really feeling the need to change and make myself stronger, it seemed to help me more without it.
But in the very beginning I had an accident that really brought me down to a break down suffering also from depression and all that, I was in bad shape, the meds were of great help in the beginning.
Now that's my story, but I think their may be some people out there that need it for a longer period of time.
Work is hard, it's about changing your mind and the way you see or percieve things, what you say to yourself, taking a look at yourself.
Not that I'm trying to give a lesson.
So many people just get lazy and would rather not go there, they want it easy by staying on meds.
If they only knew, it feels SO much better to feel your emotions, yes even when it's negative, but I didn't realize how dead I got with my emotions when I was on antidepressants, like I was half alive and numb.
I felt like I came back from the dead when I got off. :o

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 02/13/04 at 03:44 p.m.

That's just my point SnowCrystal, people with chronic Mental disorders or illness, have EVERY RIGHT to commit suicide without Physically hurting anyone else.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 02/13/04 at 03:54 p.m.

Quoting:
The time has come for Medical Science to Eliminate Mental illness and Disorders once and for all,
to merely treat them is Not enough, to keep people dependant upon Psychiatric Drugs for Decades is not the answer,
Mental Disorders and illnesses, must be CURED, Once and For all.
Their must be a way to Permanently and 100percent correct the chemical imbalances.
Yet, our President wastes Government money on the Space Program????
End Quote



I think you have your head in the clouds if you think all mental disorders and illnesses can be cured. A lot of mentally ill people have been affected in a circumstantial way and can't simply be cured in the way you expect. For example, if a person has become really depressed because a loved one has died, that can not simply be cured. If a person is damaged in any way because of an unfortunate part of their upbringing, pills are not going to shift it.

Andrew, I believe that if a person has the intention of committing suicide they will do it regardless. I don't believe there is any law that can stop them, only prevention to reduce the risk.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Tony S N Jr Fan on 02/13/04 at 03:58 p.m.


Quoting:
Why don't More people with Chronic Mental Disorders/illness,
petition the Government and Mental Health Profession to Grant them THE most fundamental Right,
The Right to commit Suicide without Physically hurting anyone else,
It is Unreasonable, doesn't anyone else think that it is for the Mental Health Profession/Gov't to expect people to live for decades dependant upon Psychiatric Drugs.

Mental Health Professionals may seem nice, but when they prevent those with chronic Mental disorders and illness from commiting suicide without physically hurting anyone else,
They are Hurting rather than helping,
they are "Just following orders"
End Quote

Andrew,
as someone who is a mental illness SURVIVOR, I have indeed tried suicide. I can tell you honestly that SUICIDE SOLVES NOTHING! I have learned that there is nothing in my life that's worth killing myself for. I would have a lot of life experiences I'd miss if I became a statistic in a graveyard. There are ways that people can GET HELP to improve their lives! As far as psychiatric drugs are concerned, they are not necessarily a bad thing. The newer drugs such as Seroquel(which I take)have more positive effects and less severe side effects. I have schizoaffective disorder,and was hospitalized repeatedly before I was put on Seroquel. I have not been back in the psych ward since 1999,which is a miracle for me! And finding support thru caring people such as self-help groups cuts down on the isolation.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: 80s_cheerleader on 02/13/04 at 03:59 p.m.


Quoting:
That's just my point SnowCrystal, people with chronic Mental disorders or illness, have EVERY RIGHT to commit suicide without Physically hurting anyone else.
End Quote



How many times do we have to say it?  Suicide is not illegal.   ::)

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Tony S N Jr Fan on 02/13/04 at 04:02 p.m.


Quoting:
People with certain mental illnesses have to take medication, otherwise they would be a danger to themselves or others.
These are people with illnesses that they were born with, like a handicap. They can't control themselves without it.
Now as for depression, anxiety, addiction, etc., meds are just a tool (suppose to be, atleast) to help them So they can help themselves by going through therapy and everything they need to do to get better.
It's a booster.
But if they don't bother doing any work, they don't get better, they just depend on the meds.

End Quote

How true! I find that having supportive people around me helps me a lot,since they can offer advice on some of life's matters, big and small!

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 02/13/04 at 04:07 p.m.

Quoting:
That's just my point SnowCrystal, people with chronic Mental disorders or illness, have EVERY RIGHT to commit suicide without Physically hurting anyone else.
End Quote



I'm sorry Andrew, I've read SnowCrystals posts and they don't seem to say anything about having the right/not having the right to commit suicide. First she referred to the need for general use of medication and then described her own courage in the way she dealt with her own illness which, if nothing else portrays a positive message not a message of suicide - Good on you girl.

Correct me if I am wrong and I have missed something out, SnowCrystal.  ;)

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Snowcrystal on 02/13/04 at 04:21 p.m.

When you say chronic mental illness, are you saying people with disability type mental illness like manic depression, schitzophrenia (I know I spelled that wrong), bipolar?
If so, and they are suppose to be on meds in order to keep themselves in control but chose not to, I would hope someone would try to keep them from killing themselves, cuz they wouldn't be in the right state of mind when they're doing it.
If someone knows they have to take meds to stay in control, knowing that they can be harmful to themselves or others, that would be like a crime. Like an alcoholic, knowing he/she's an alcoholic choosing to drink.
Now, if you are talking about terminal illness, that's a hard one. I've heard some real miracle stories, and I would Hope that when someone really wants to "go" that maybe they should be allowed to make that choice, but it's so hard to know if it's really right.
If there's no cure or no way that a person can recover, why should they be forced to continue suffering if they don't want it anymore, doesn't it just get worse instead of better. That would be wrong to not let them choose.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Bobby on 02/13/04 at 04:21 p.m.

What I am encouraged by on this thread is the amount of people that are successfully dealing with their own illnesses. People like Absolutely Vile, Howard, Nascarnut, Lyricboy, Snowcrystal, Tony SN Jnr Fan. This is what life is about! We get one chance at it!

If you just looked at what you are posting Andrew and see that it is all rhetoric, you may hopefully see a different perspective. Until you listen to other people and understand this, I think there is nothing more I can say.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Snowcrystal on 02/13/04 at 04:25 p.m.

You are right Bobby, thank you:)
I'm confused ::)

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 02/14/04 at 11:07 a.m.

I used to take 2 medications 2 times a week.Anaframil & Prozac for my OCD. (1993-1999)

Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 02/15/04 at 10:32 a.m.

Yes, but Howard, how does it make you feel that the Mental Health Profession forces people to live dependant upon Psychiatric drugs.
Until people with Chronic Mental disorders and illnesses are granted the Right to commit suicide without physically hurting anyone else, they will never be truly free.
The Mental Health Profession and/or Government has NO right to prevent those with chronic mental disorders/illness from commiting suicide, those with chronic mental disorders and illness that commit suicide without hurting anyone else are in my opinion "Freedom Fighters" doing an act of Supreme Rebellion against the Mental Health Profession, they are Fighting the good fight.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 02/15/04 at 10:33 a.m.

To Howard, also I forgot to ask, if you commited suicide, do you think God would make you Re-live your OCD Nightmare or would God forgive you.?

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Absolutely_Vile on 02/15/04 at 11:59 a.m.


Quoting:
Yes, but Howard, how does it make you feel that the Mental Health Profession forces people to live dependant upon Psychiatric drugs.End Quote



NO ONE IN THE PSYCHIATRIC FIELD FORCES ANYONE TO DO ANYTHING ANYMORE! It's a thing of the past!!!

Quoting:Until people with Chronic Mental disorders and illnesses are granted the Right to commit suicide without physically hurting anyone else, they will never be truly free.End Quote



How does suicide physically hurt other people besides the one committing suicide? That's something I never understood about all this. It emotionally affects people, but I doubt it physically affects them, unless they suffer physical strife due to their emotional reaction to the suicide.

Quoting:The Mental Health Profession and/or Government has NO right to prevent those with chronic mental disorders/illness from commiting suicide, those with chronic mental disorders and illness that commit suicide without hurting anyone else are in my opinion "Freedom Fighters" doing an act of Supreme Rebellion against the Mental Health Profession, they are Fighting the good fight.
End Quote



NO ONE IS PREVENTING ANYONE FROM DOING ANYTHING! People will commit suicide whether other people want them to or not. They won't give a sh*t what their friends, family, the government or mental health professionals do or say. So they're not "freedom fighters." In fact, they're not giving themselves a chance to live the life they could live if they just bothered to get some help to sort themselves out before they got to that point!

<sigh> I give up. This is getting so redundant, it's ridiculous. Obviously having several people repeat the same points over and over and over again just isn't getting through. I'll post to this if I ever have something new and different to say...or if I need to vent my frustration again. Argh.

Absolutely Vile

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Andrew-CoolestDude on 02/15/04 at 12:15 a.m.

Yes, not to be offensive, but in America today, if Mental Health Professionals think you are suicidal they can hospitalize you against your will.

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 02/15/04 at 12:36 a.m.


Quoting:
Yes, but Howard, how does it make you feel that the Mental Health Profession forces people to live dependant upon Psychiatric drugs.
Until people with Chronic Mental disorders and illnesses are granted the Right to commit suicide without physically hurting anyone else, they will never be truly free.
The Mental Health Profession and/or Government has NO right to prevent those with chronic mental disorders/illness from commiting suicide, those with chronic mental disorders and illness that commit suicide without hurting anyone else are in my opinion "Freedom Fighters" doing an act of Supreme Rebellion against the Mental Health Profession, they are Fighting the good fight.
End Quote



I'm sorry but I don't feel like answering that right now. >:(

Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Howard on 02/15/04 at 12:38 a.m.


Quoting:
To Howard, also I forgot to ask, if you commited suicide, do you think God would make you Re-live your OCD Nightmare or would God forgive you.?
End Quote



I'm sorry Andrew you're asking way too much.I don't want to answer that at the moment! >:(

Howard

Subject: Re: Rights of the Mentally ill-Several Points

Written By: Hairspray on 02/15/04 at 04:32 p.m.


Quoting:
...if you commited suicide, do you think God would make you Re-live your OCD Nightmare or would God forgive you.?
End Quote



I'll take this question -

Hello!

You kill yourself, you die.

There is absolutely no certainty of the existence of an afterlife.

So, there very-well may be no afterlife to re-suffer from anything.

No forgiveness of any kind would apply and even if it somehow did, you should know by now as a christian that killing yourself or anyone is a sin.

Ok Andrew, this thread is another casualty. It's like a recurring nightmare that just won't go away. The repetition gets tiresome. Don't start another thread on this subject. It will get deleted.