Welcome to the archived messages from In The 00s. This archive stretches back to 1998 in some instances, and contains a nearly complete record of all the messages posted to inthe00s.com. You will also find an archive of the messages from inthe70s.com, inthe80s.com, inthe90s.com and amiright.com before they were combined to form the inthe00s.com messageboard.
If you are looking for the active messages, please click here. Otherwise, use the links below or on the right hand side of the page to navigate the archives.
Subject: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Cheering
I just had to post what I'm seeing and reading about right now.
Thoughts?
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
8) 8)I never thought most of them .liked saddam,and now they feel thay can say nwhat they want to without worrying about reprisals.Cheers!
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
What I saw looks good so far. I've expressed my pesimism and just hope, for everyone's sake that I was wrong. Never thought that winning the war would be hard though. Its winning the peace that will really count. I'm still not optimistic, but willing to be convinced.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
I wish I could be home so I could see images of it. I am happy for all of those people who will benefit for this!
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Three cheers!
HIP HIP HOORAY!
HIP HIP HOORAY!
HIP HIP HOORAY!
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
I've expressed my pesimism and just hope, for everyone's sake that I was wrong.
End Quote
Me, too. Things are looking a bit too good to be true at the moment, but fingers crossed...
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
I am currently watching a clip of a US Marine being hoisted up by Iraqis to wrap a flag around the head of a giant statue of Saddam.
And they are showing a city-full of Iraqis marching down the street with American flags chanting "down with Saddam, long live US".
Its a good day for sure. :)
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
The Saddam statue has been brought down. These people look happy and are hailing Bush as their hero. There was one camera shot of an Iraqi man kissing a picture of Bush.
That kind of happiness is genuine and I'm happy for those people. Only they could really know and truly understand what they have been liberated from. Good for them! :)
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
I guess this is as good a place as any...
"The game is over."
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
It's good that the war is pretty much over. I'm glad that we were well recieved by the Iraqi people, BUT I think we will have to reconstruct more than just Iraq when this war is over. We have a lot of making up to do between the European countries that we alienated through GWB's cowboy diplomacy. This war would have caused a lot less grief if we could have been more patient with the rest of the world. We should have waited for things like proof before we went in.
The diplomacy of GWB (or lack there-of) made this war a bitter pill to swallow and now we will have to deal with the consequences.
Will we be able to salvage the UN or is it doomed to follow the path of the League of Nations? It's in our hands.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
You can flush Europe all you want, but we still need their buisiness if we are going to get out of this recession. That's not my opinion, that's economics.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
We have a lot of making up to do between the European countries that we alienated through GWB's cowboy diplomacy.End Quote
I respectfully disagree. We tried to get them involved as much as was possible, but they chose to alienate themselves by not wanting any part of it.
Quoting:
This war would have caused a lot less grief if we could have been more patient with the rest of the world. We should have waited for things like proof before we went in.End Quote
We do not know that this war would have caused a lot less grief if we could have been more patient with the rest of the world and we never will. I think, judging by Iraqi reaction, they had waited long enough for their liberation from the madman and his atrocious regime.
Quoting:
The diplomacy of GWB (or lack there-of) made this war a bitter pill to swallow and now we will have to deal with the consequences.End Quote
Evidently, this was the only way this war would have ever happened. George W. Bush is the only one who could have pulled it off too, with his "cowboy" mentality.
As far as consequences...
What are you referring to, specifically?
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
You can flush Europe all you want, but we still need their buisiness if we are going to get out of this recession. That's not my opinion, that's economics.
End Quote
They'd trade with us anyway.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
(this was posted earlier but I accidentally hit the "Remove" button, luckily I saved it when I was revising it)
Quoting:
We have a lot of making up to do between the European countries that we alienated through GWB's cowboy diplomacy. This war would have caused a lot less grief if we could have been more patient with the rest of the world. We should have waited for things like proof before we went in.End Quote
hey, GW's "cowboy diplomacy" is what produced the amazing footage and pictures we saw today of the Iraqis fiinally getting a taste of freedom for the first time in their lives.
If you want to continue to protest it, make sure you emphasize its YOUR opinion, and not the rest of America's.
PS- to all those protestors who carried signs saying "NOT IN OUR NAME", by all means keep it that way. When I see the Iraqis kissing pictures of Bush and chanting "USA USA" like they did today, we'll all remember their first taste of liberation and freedom was Not in YOUR Name. Who needs ya.
Quoting:The diplomacy of GWB (or lack there-of) made this war a bitter pill to swallow and now we will have to deal with the consequences.End Quote
Consquences?
Could you have a more negative outlook? Doubt it.
Call me crazy, but liberating a country from a brutal, murdering ruler is not a bad thing, despite what you and CNN seem to think it is.
Quoting:Will we be able to salvage the UN or is it doomed to follow the path of the League of Nations? It's in our hands.
End Quote
again, had we waited around for the UN to do their useless "inspections", the Iraqis would not have been able to celebrate, like they did today.
The UN building can collapse and crumble into the river as far as I'm concerned. ;)
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
You can flush Europe all you want, but we still need their buisiness if we are going to get out of this recession. That's not my opinion, that's economics.
End Quote
So the self proclaimed Socialist wants to give us a lesson in economics? Don't comment on something you may not understand.
Edited because we're trying to cut down on the personal insults, per Forum Guidelines.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
You can flush Europe all you want, but we still need their buisiness if we are going to get out of this recession. That's not my opinion, that's economics.
End Quote
Wow John. I guess you really don't get it.
Money is money, and even if it comes from a country you absolutely hate, its still money.
Like Rice said, they will still trade with us. Even if they absolutley hate America, if they want our business as 99.9% of the world does, they will do whatever they can to do business with us.
Thats economics sonny.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
First of this is a wonderful thing to view, please anti-war people dont choose not to see it. Aknowledge success even when it's not expected.
George W and the admin have communicated very clearly the threat, changes necessary to remove that threat, action to be taken if demands not met, and lastly very clear time lines which that action will take place.
I don't recall an admin since Reagan (to young to vote, but wouldn't have back then if I could) that has made their agenda more clear, George W may not be as great a speaker as Clinton but he has proven his words have weight.
If this cowboy politics then I choose that over the "spin" politics we sat through for to long.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Money is money, and even if it comes from a country you absolutely hate, its still money.
Like Rice said, they will still trade with us. Even if they absolutley hate America, if they want our business as 99.9% of the world does, they will do whatever they can to do business with us.
End Quote
Well, I was thinking more in terms of whether we absolutely need anything from Europe that we can't make or grow here in the United States. But I'm betting that Europe needs America more than America needs Europe.
No offense to anyone, just my personal opinion.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
First of this is a wonderful thing to view, please anti-war people dont choose not to see it. Aknowledge success even when it's not expected.
George W and the admin have communicated very clearly the threat, changes necessary to remove that threat, action to be taken if demands not met, and lastly very clear time lines which that action will take place.
I don't recall an admin since Reagan (to young to vote, but wouldn't have back then if I could) that has made their agenda more clear, George W may not be as great a speaker as Clinton but he has proven his words have weight.
If this cowboy politics then I choose that over the "spin" politics we sat through for to long.
End Quote
Personally I think we, as the world in general, were anesthetised(sp?) by the wussy all talk and no action politics of our last...eh hum..."president".
And now that we have one who says what he's going to do and does what he says, some people don't know how to react.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Personally I think we, as the world in general, we anesthetised(sp?) by the wussy all talk and no action politics of our last...eh hum..."president".
And now that we have one who says what he's going to do and does what he says, some people don't know how to react.
End Quote
Exactly, one of the final straws that broke my democratic back, the lack of spine in Clinton. George, whether you believe in his polices or not, at least you can expect him to clearly state, and keep, his word.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
This isn't over by a long shot. This is only the beginning. You can look at the symbolisim of the US flag draped around Saddam's statue's head more than one way. You are looking at it as VICTORY!!
How do you think the Arab world is looking at the same scene?
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
This isn't over by a long shot. This is only the beginning. End Quote
I'm afraid it's not!
The celebrating Iraqis are in fact only a small minority, mainly Shias. I don't think this can be taken as evidence of much. I'm pretty sure you would get the same reaction in any country, there are always opposition to the current regime and even people who simply want to ingratiate themselves with the conquerers!
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Personally I think we, as the world in general, were anesthetised(sp?) by the wussy all talk and no action politics of our last...eh hum..."president".
And now that we have one who says what he's going to do and does what he says, some people don't know how to react.
End Quote
Read your own post. "....we, as the world in general...." "And now that we have one....."
So your speaking for the world in general now?
Your.....eh hum....... current "president", as much as he strives to be, and you and your right wing buds fantasize that he is, is not our (the world in general) president.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Well I have to say that I too believe this is far from over.I think it's great that Sadam has gone but this is another country that will need years if not decades of aid and support to get back on it's feet,as well as careful handling.The Arabic way of life and culture is very different to ours in the West and they do just happen to supply nearly all our oil .........
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
This isn't over by a long shot. This is only the beginning. You can look at the symbolisim of the US flag draped around Saddam's statue's head more than one way. You are looking at it as VICTORY!!
How do you think the Arab world is looking at the same scene?
End Quote
Good question. I've heard the heavy brass at the Pentagon went nuclear when they saw the US flag over the head, and it was quickly replaced with the pre-1991 Iraqi flag.
If "this" is the aggressive Coalition presence in Iraq... well, if it's not over it's entering the end-game. If "this" is explosive and revolutionary change in the Middle East, centering in Iraq, than yes, it's just beginning.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Read your own post. "....we, as the world in general...." "And now that we have one....."
So your speaking for the world in general now?
Your.....eh hum....... current "president", as much as he strives to be, and you and your right wing buds fantasize that he is, is not our (the world in general) president.
End Quote
Pardon me, but it seems you took the statement out of context, or you just see it differently than I do.
So the way I read it, 80sRocked was talking about our last President. That would be the US President, not the French president or the Canadian Prime Minister or the Shah of Iran (who I guess no longer exists, but whatever). And what he's basically saying is that our last President (let's call him "Bubba"), albeit a smooth talker, was not a man of action. But this current US President (let's call him "Dubya"), although admittedly a BAD public speaker, has the gumption and the gall to "meddle" in world affairs in an effort to rid the world of an imminent threat. 80sRocked's statement just says that the world preferred Bubba over Dubya because Bubba didn't care, and the world got used to Bubba's non-caring and associated the United States as a whole with it, so they were not prepared for Dubya's gung-ho attitude.
At least that's how I see it.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Very well said, Rice. :)
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Seeing people in Iraq flashing signs of "Thanks America" and praising us for ousting sadaam is wonderful....take THAT rosie and your clan of idiots!
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Read your own post. "....we, as the world in general...." "And now that we have one....."
So your speaking for the world in general now?
Your.....eh hum....... current "president", as much as he strives to be, and you and your right wing buds fantasize that he is, is not our (the world in general) president.
End Quote
I love you, peeps, whoever you are :)
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
I really think it is too early to be celebrating. We know that the Iraqis are free from Hussen, which is good, but at what cost? So far, many have died-Americans, British, and Iraqis.
What is going to happen to Iraq now? Is the US going to help rebuild what it destroyed? Are we going to let them fend for themselves like we did Afganistan so that a Taliban-type government can come into power? Or are we going to create a government for them like we did in Iran and put a Shah-type figurehead to do the US's bidding? Is there going to be a government where all the fractions of Iraqi society are represented or will one group dominate and surpress the others.
Another thing to concider, if other nations are going to use the US example of pre-empted strikes at their "enemies." This is far from over. We may not know how this will all play out for years to come. I am just a little cautious about celebrating.
Cat
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Read your own post. "....we, as the world in general...." "And now that we have one....."
So your speaking for the world in general now?
Your.....eh hum....... current "president", as much as he strives to be, and you and your right wing buds fantasize that he is, is not our (the world in general) president.
End Quote
...please see Rice Cube's post. Then maybe you will understand what I was trying to say. ;) (thanks Rice by the way)
Of course GWB isn't the world's president per say, But being in the position he is in, as is any US president, he has a lot of power worldwide. And "Bubba" was a man of "all bark and no bite", and the world knoew he was nothing more than a horny-smooth-talking-lying-wussy-pushover.
Thank God GWB isn't afraid to actually do something.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
I'm not going to call this mission a success until the whole of Iraq is rebuilt and the people have an elected government looking out for them that is allowed to say "No" to the United States. How many of the democratic principles that we hold so important will be suspended in Iraq as they have been in other countries? Iran, the Philippines, most of Central America ...? Will we make another blunder like overthrowing an elected Iranian Prime Minister for petrol concerns? Will we screw up again like we did when we assisted the Ba'ath party to power in Iraq?
I find it interesting how many of the war dogs are finding vindication at this phase of the war. It tends toward the presumption that the victory comes when we stop invading and start occupying. And that's a foolish presumption.
It warms my heart to see the Iraqis welcoming their liberators, but I remember many days when making someone smile was all I could do; it didn't mean they would be happy come tomorrow.
The liberation is obviously not complete, and should not be spoken of in the past tense, as recent developments show. Someone would wish to speak of the suffering of the Iraqi people? Someone, please, quantify it. As issues in the DRC show, focus on the Iraqis ignores greater human disasters around the world. What separates our concern for the Iraqis, as opposed to Zimbabwe, DRC, or even North Korea, is that the Iraqis are more important because they have oil. A human disaster is a human disaster regardless of nation or ethnicity. If we're going to tackle the world's problems, let's do it according to some better priority than who has the best earning and spending potential; they're all humans, and they all deserve dignity. And some of us are sick and tired of signing on for these half-assed adventures that bring victory only in the military sense that the enemy (e.g. Saddam Hussein) has been defeated. The actual condition of the Iraqi people, one of the motivators for this war, is generally unimportant to those who sponsor this war.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Thanks Davester - very well said. Let me add an observation: Have you ever heard a US gov't official refer to our "democratic allies" in the M.E.? No, they are "moderate Arab states", but not democracies. Nor are we pushing them to become democratic. Democracy in Iraq? If it comes my bet is that the Shiia majority will vote for an Islamic theocracy similar (if we're lucky) to Iran's, or worse, like the Taliban. Will we allow that version of a democratic outcome? Don't bet on it.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
I'm not going to call this mission a success until the whole of Iraq is rebuilt and the people have an elected government looking out for them that is allowed to say "No" to the United States.End Quote
*In a George Bush Sr. tone*: Not gonna happen.
That would defeat the purpose of our intervening. I wouldn't hold my breath for what you're asking.
Quoting:How many of the democratic principles that we hold so important will be suspended in Iraq as they have been in other countries? Iran, the Philippines, most of Central America ...?End Quote
They don't need those things now. What they need is a strong leader who will rule the different factions of Iraq with an iron fist, yet will be west-friendly (such as the Shah of Iran or maybe even another Tito), until things settle down. Try implementing democratic ideals now into and they'll soon be steeped in a civil war.
Quoting:Will we make another blunder like overthrowing an elected Iranian Prime Minister for petrol concerns? Will we screw up again like we did when we assisted the Ba'ath party to power in Iraq?End Quote
They all served their purpose: Ours.
Quoting:I find it interesting how many of the war dogs are finding vindication at this phase of the war. It tends toward the presumption that the victory comes when we stop invading and start occupying. And that's a foolish presumption.End Quote
I don't. Those are some other people. What I do want to come from this is success since our nation has committed itself to this task and we're running up a large tab, so there better be benefits that come from this. This goes besides the casualties of our troops out there who are fighting to secure our way of life.
Quoting:.. Someone would wish to speak of the suffering of the Iraqi people? Someone, please, quantify it. As issues in the DRC show, focus on the Iraqis ignores greater human disasters around the world.End Quote
And?
Quoting:What separates our concern for the Iraqis, as opposed to Zimbabwe, DRC, or even North Korea, is that the Iraqis are more important because they have oil. A human disaster is a human disaster regardless of nation or ethnicity.End Quote
What you're asking is that we fight on all fronts on kindness alone?
Quoting:If we're going to tackle the world's problems, let's do it according to some better priority than who has the best earning and spending potential...End Quote
But that's how things are done in the real world. That's why you and I are here comfortably discussing this horrible matter in clinical tones. If you're really revolted then, by all means, boycott America. Stop eating at the fast-food restaurants, don't buy cigarrettes, stop purchasing clothes, don't eat vegetables and fruits, don't buy precious metals, don't use the computers, and God forbid you shouldn't drive a car. Do you think it better pointing out the faults when your stomach is full? Seriously, where does it stop? When is it okay to freely accept things as human nature running its course and when should you be angry and sickened by the results of it? Every bit of comfort and luxury you subconsciously enjoy while living in this nation buys into the plotting and scheming that goes on elsewhere - and we're not talking about Zimbabwe here. Zimbabwe bears little relevance on our life's activities, but Iraq does.
Quoting:And some of us are sick and tired of signing on for these half-assed adventures that bring victory only in the military sense that the enemy (e.g. Saddam Hussein) has been defeated. The actual condition of the Iraqi people, one of the motivators for this war, is generally unimportant to those who sponsor this war.End Quote
So don't sign. You have freewill. Use it.
Out of your own volition you choose to not do anything substantial to make a change for what you believe is "right." Out of my own volition, I have accepted this as life and won't be spouting with my mouth full.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
That would defeat the purpose of our intervening. I wouldn't hold my breath for what you're asking.
End Quote
I'm not.
Quoting:
They don't need those things now. What they need is a strong leader who will rule the different factions of Iraq with an iron fist, yet will be west-friendly (such as the Shah of Iran or maybe even another Tito), until things settle down. Try implementing democratic ideals now into and they'll soon be steeped in a civil war.
End Quote
The Iraqi Shi'ite Muslims haven't breathed freely in over two millennia. The situation in Iraq is that the current generation has no clue what it's like to be free and not be exploited. The operating assumption there is that people are subjects of a government, not that government is an institution of the people. We have to overcome this problem before we can help build a free society anywhere in the oppressed Islamic world.
Ask yourself why the internal Iraqi opposition parties are being frozen out of the game? Because they don't get the freedom rap, either. It's not the raising of the Iraqi people they're interested in as much as it is being the next guy in charge. We're happy to play ball with the international dispersal of Iraqi opposition because they're playing ball more like we're used to. But as a practical matter, you're going to have to deal with people who are used to being told what to do as well as people for whom freedom is the right to oppress others.
Quoting:
They all served their purpose: Ours.
End Quote
I can't argue with that.
Quoting:
I don't. Those are some other people. What I do want to come from this is success since our nation has committed itself to this task and we're running up a large tab, so there better be benefits that come from this. This goes besides the casualties of our troops out there who are fighting to secure our way of life.
End Quote
Secure our way of life..a.k.a. "protecting our freedom", I've heard these thrown aound so much, lately...
I think sappy appeals like those above are detrimental to our armed services; they cast military action in a dishonest light, and it is, after all, in part, American integrity that the world is arguing right now as we abrogate our international agreements to stage an invasion of a country we helped ruin by supporting a criminal regime.
It's just really hard to respect the people who are "protecting our freedom" when they are, in fact, doing nothing of the sort. I prefer my soldiers in terrain-appropriate camouflage, not in sheep's clothing. Of course, on a practical level, it would probably do me no good to tell the Iraqis that; but it makes sense that Hussein would create such a circumstance. But still, when we send our soldiers forth to actually protect us, I'll openly support them. At present, however, we have a volunteer army staging an invasion of a foreign nation without immediate cause and in violation of multiple international agreements which the United States has chosen to enter.
And I just don't know quite what to think about that. I fully expect to be beaten about the head and shoulders for this view. :-X
Quoting:
And?
End Quote
Nice reply, but it leaves me wanting...
Quoting:
What you're asking is that we fight on all fronts on kindness alone..
End Quote
I think you know what I'm talking about. I'll let you re-read my post and reflect upon it.
Quoting:
But that's how things are done in the real world. That's why you and I are here comfortably discussing this horrible matter in clinical tones. If you're really revolted then, by all means, boycott America. Stop eating at the fast-food restaurants, don't buy cigarrettes, stop purchasing clothes, don't eat vegetables and fruits, don't buy precious metals, don't use the computers, and God forbid you shouldn't drive a car. Do you think it better pointing out the faults when your stomach is full? Seriously, where does it stop? When is it okay to freely accept things as human nature running its course and when should you be angry and sickened by the results of it? Every bit of comfort and luxury you subconsciously enjoy while living in this nation buys into the plotting and scheming that goes on elsewhere - and we're not talking about Zimbabwe here. Zimbabwe bears little relevance on our life's activities, but Iraq does.
End Quote
Oh please don't give me the "Love It Or Leave It" rap again...been there, done that, bought the f***ing t-shirt...next..? ::)
Quoting:
So don't sign. You have freewill. Use it.
Out of your own volition you choose to not do anything substantial to make a change for what you believe is "right." Out of my own volition, I have accepted this as life and won't be spouting with my mouth full.
End Quote
See above.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
 Secure our way of life..a.k.a. "protecting our freedom", I've heard these thrown aound so much, lately...End Quote
Our way of life includes the use of gasoline, the creation of the biggest pile of waste in the world, the overconsumption, etc. Yes, all of it. You buy into it just as much as the next the guy, so don't condescend to lumping my opinion with what you've "heard so much lately" because you haven't. I never mentioned anything about "freedom." What we want foremost is to freely consume... that is what I was getting at.
Quoting:I think sappy appeals like those above are detrimental to our armed services; they cast military action in a dishonest light, and it is, after all, in part, American integrity that the world is arguing right now as we abrogate our international agreements to stage an invasion of a country we helped ruin by supporting a criminal regime.End Quote
Therefore, going to Zimbabwe is going to put us in a new light. I see where you're getting with this.
Quoting:It's just really hard to respect the people who are "protecting our freedom" when they are, in fact, doing nothing of the sort.End Quote
It's just really hard to respect a nay-sayers's opinion when they eat off the same trough as the other animals.
Quoting:Nice reply, but it leaves me wanting...End Quote
There's nothing more for me to add. I'm not an idealist.
Otoh, your's leave me more than satisfied.
Quoting:I think you know what I'm talking about. Â I'll let you re-read my post and reflect upon it.End Quote
So you do want to us to fight on all fronts on kindness alone...
Quoting:Oh please don't give me the "Love It Or Leave It" rap again...been there, done that, bought the f***ing t-shirt...next..? ::)End Quote
Where, may I ask, did I state such a thing? I merely stated that if you're so revolted and dissatisfied with the status quo of this nation's tactics (which provides for all your enjoyment of life's better things), then you should do something pro-active instead of whine your guilty consumerist conscience away and mask it as good intentions and being for peace. I don't give you anything. You have given yourself this dilemma, now deal with it and don't blame others for thinking rationally. Think about it next time you take a drive somewhere to cool off and pull out a pack of smokes...
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Zimbabwe bears little relevance on our life's activities, but Iraq does.
End Quote
So because it doesn't affect "us", we can just ignore it. Yep, you're right. That's human nature, all right.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
So because it doesn't affect "us", we can just ignore it. Yep, you're right. That's human nature, all right.
End Quote
Pardon me for asking, because I'm not completely sure of it...but aren't most African nations former European colonies? So maybe a European coalition would be more suited to dealing with nations like Zimbabwe.
Just a thought.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Hey, I've got it! Why don't we send Tim Robbins and Susan Sarandon and Michael Moore to Zimbabwe and have them flash peace signs at the warring factions. ;D (I'm sure France and Germany would approve...)
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Pardon me for asking, because I'm not completely sure of it...but aren't most African nations former European colonies? So maybe a European coalition would be more suited to dealing with nations like Zimbabwe.
Just a thought.
End Quote
Zimbabwe used to be Rhodesia. At the last Commonwealth Heads of Government meeting there was a call to suspend Zimbabwe from the Commonwealth, but the big guns like Australia opposed it! The ironic thing about Zimbabwe is that it is the white farmers who are being forced off their lands and slaughtered by black rebels who are being supported by the black president who was brought to power by the whites.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
So because it doesn't affect "us", we can just ignore it. Yep, you're right. That's human nature, all right.
End Quote
You're catching on. I mean, if Zimbabwe was supporting Hezbollah, had oil reserves, and was correctly placed on a world map, then I would agree that US intervention would sound rational.
I certainly hope you also do not believe on fighting world injustices on kindness alone. It is unpractical and inefficient for our purposes. If we're not looking out for number one, who will?
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
It is unpractical and inefficient for our purposes.
End Quote
And those purposes are..? What an extraordinarily arrogant thing to say.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Seeing as how Zimbabwe is a member of the Commonwealth, what exactly should the United States do about it?
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
But it's true. We can't go into every place where human rights are being abused and fix things; there's too many of them and we don't have the resources. I mean, ideally, we'd go in and correct all the abuses in, say, China, but it's not going to happen.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Seeing as how Zimbabwe is a member of the Commonwealth, what exactly should the United States do about it?
End Quote
Nothing of course. It should just sit by and watch it be torn apart by a corrupt leader with no consideration for human rights until it starts rattling a sabre at Washington.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
And those purposes are..? What an extraordinarily arrogant thing to say.
End Quote
I know a topic is running out of new things to say when repetition becomes the norm.
The purposes are to maintain our way of life. What I write may come off as arrogant to you, but at least it's not unrealistic. Consumerism, economics, luxuries and comforts, selfishness, the GDP, inflation, cost of living, hedonism, lazyness and stupidity, apathy, poverty, geo-economics: Those are all facts of life. They have to be spoken for too.
This nation (and yours) provides and encourages the daisy-chain ideology of others to be spoken for as loudly as one may feel like and they also secure thoughts like mine. The truth is hardly ever pleasant, so people are welcome to not like it and I am glad to read well-written and well-thought out dissenting ideas. I am also glad they get to reap and enjoy the benefits from the cruel and underhanded tactics of our foreign policy.
I think that once idealists resort to simple one-sentence answers and not the usual long-winded, agitated verbiage is when the air has fully escaped from the bag.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Nothing of course. It should just sit by and watch it be torn apart by a corrupt leader with no consideration for human rights until it starts rattling a sabre at Washington.
End Quote
Are you saying "nothing" sarcastically?
If not, if you believe the United States should do something, what do you recommend?
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Hey, I've got it! Why don't we send Tim Robbins and Susan Sarandon and Michael Moore to Zimbabwe and have them flash peace signs at the warring factions. ;D (I'm sure France and Germany would approve...)
End Quote
hey I'm all for that idea! :D
Hey and don't forget Martin Sheen, he could be their leader. After all he does seem to think that just because he plays a pres on TV, that makes him a real pres in real life. ::)
it would do a lot of them some good to actually see first-hand what they are trying to protest against. (much like many of the human shields who went to Iraq until they realized the Iraqis wanted them to get out).
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
The purposes are to maintain our way of life. What I write may come off as arrogant to you, but at least it's not unrealistic. Consumerism, economics, luxuries and comforts, selfishness, the GDP, inflation, cost of living, hedonism, lazyness and stupidity, apathy, poverty, geo-economics: Those are all facts of life. They have to be spoken for too.
This nation (and yours) provides and encourages the daisy-chain ideology of others to be spoken for as loudly as one may feel like and they also secure thoughts like mine. The truth is hardly ever pleasant, so people are welcome to not like it and I am glad to read well-written and well-thought out dissenting ideas. I am also glad they get to reap and enjoy the benefits from the cruel and underhanded tactics of our foreign policy.
End Quote
Indeed it is arrogant, but you are correct: it is realistic. Believe me when I say that I am keenly aware of the points you have made in this post. You are forthright in stating that US foreign policy is primarily concerned with maintaining the US way of life, first, last and always. Liberating an oppressed nation along the way may help the country to look noble as well, but we should remember that the primary reason the war was undertaken wasn't to free Iraq from Saddam, but to free the US from a perceived danger.
Believe me, I know exactly what you're saying. All countries have the responsibility to look after their own interests before that of others and often need to use cruel and underhanded tactics in order to do so, not only in foreign policy matters but often in domestic situations as well. My point here has been to highlight the obvious double standards that are employed by administrations as part of these tactics. Do we have the right to condemn one nation for doing openly what another (including our own) does in secret? Of course not. But if we can claim that we're doing it for the greater good while "they" are doing it for nefarious reasions, at least we can justify it to ourselves. And if that keeps the people happy and maintains our way of life, why should we argue?
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
...please see Rice Cube's post. Then maybe you will understand what I was trying to say. ;) (thanks Rice by the way)
Of course GWB isn't the world's president per say, But being in the position he is in, as is any US president, he has a lot of power worldwide. And "Bubba" was a man of "all bark and no bite", and the world knoew he was nothing more than a horny-smooth-talking-lying-wussy-pushover.
Thank God GWB isn't afraid to actually do something.
End Quote
OK, that is your take on what the rest of the world is thinking..........here is mine.
I think they sat back and watched in amazement as the right wing spent billions of the taxpayer's dollars and hundreds of hours of the legislative and judicial branches of the government's time investigating a President of The United States getting a hum#3r in the Oval Office, and nearly getting him booted out of office for lying about something that millions of men around the world have lied about.The most investigated man in the history of the world, and that is the worst they could get on him. And oh yeah, by the way, THAT WAS 5 YEARS AGO!! Get over it.
And now they watch as a cowboy, ex frat boy, daddy wannabe, who was put into office, not by a majority of the votes, but by an outdated, good ol' boy system and the billions of right wing dollars, who hasn't got the intelligence to run a baseball team, much less a country, but is there as a figurehead for George Sr., Cheney, Rumsfeld, and all the rest of the idiots that still hang on to Ronald Reagen like he was a God, sends us into a war that the majority of the world knows is wrong, and uses the fear of terrorisim to slowly suck our Constitutional Rights out from under us.
That is my take on how the rest of the world looks at us.
Lets let the people on this board that actually are from other countries judge who has the clearer take on how they view us........OK?
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Good morning, peeps 8)
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Good morning TB........BTW, how do you know it is morning where I reside? 8) :o
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Good morning TB........BTW, how do you know it is morning where I reside? 8) :o
End Quote
We toys can see everythiiiiiiing :) :D ;D
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Hi Hs, :)
Hmm, well, I'll retake the topic. ::)Yes, I also saw the pictures of the Irakis celebrating the so-called liberation but I have also seen quite scary pictures, like those showing looting n destruction. :-/
And honestly, I think that now it's the Kurdish who can n will celebrate... Now they have carte blanche to go n take whatever they fancy. :( "Hey, look, nice carpet, let's take it to Kurdistan". "What about looting the whole country, we Kurdish will help n liberate the country n will do them a favour by devasting the whole place, including hospitals"...How sad, isn't it? :-/
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,5944-643304,00.html
::) Maybe the USA intentions (at least the ones they proclamed or the theoric reasons to send in troops to Irak) were good but honestly, they got in their way. If I were an Iraki n some1 told me now about freedom, now that the place's been looted n few people had real future, I couldn't care less... What's left when you've been looted n have no money, no job n nothing to eat...?
War cuts both ways...And that's true, unfortunately...I really hope the reconstructions plans the USA talks about work n can be carried out soon.Because in the meanwhile, many people suffer each day n no1 stops the devastion n the looting. Something Irakis have already started to get used to.
Delia
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Apology for the word "idiots" in the previous post. :-[ (for that word and that word only)
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
OK, that is your take on what the rest of the world is thinking..........here is mine.
I think they sat back and watched in amazement as the right wing spent billions of the taxpayer's dollars and hundreds of hours of the legislative and judicial branches of the government's time investigating a President of The United States getting a hum#3r in the Oval Office, and nearly getting him booted out of office for lying about something that millions of men around the world have lied about.The most investigated man in the history of the world, and that is the worst they could get on him. And oh yeah, by the way, THAT WAS 5 YEARS AGO!! Get over it.
And now they watch as a cowboy, ex frat boy, daddy wannabe, who was put into office, not by a majority of the votes, but by an outdated, good ol' boy system and the billions of right wing dollars, who hasn't got the intelligence to run a baseball team, much less a country, but is there as a figurehead for George Sr., Cheney, Rumsfeld, and all the rest of the idiots that still hang on to Ronald Reagen like he was a God, sends us into a war that the majority of the world knows is wrong, and uses the fear of terrorisim to slowly suck our Constitutional Rights out from under us.
That is my take on how the rest of the world looks at us.
Lets let the people on this board that actually are from other countries judge who has the clearer take on how they view us........OK?
End Quote
well then.
At the risk of possibly saying something I might regret, I'll be the bigger man.
How are you today? :)
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
I've been against Bush and this war from the beginning. My mind hasn't changed. I never doubted that the USA would topple Saddam in one way or another. I never doubted that Saddam was a tyranical dictator who should be gone. But the after-Saddam period will be much harder than the "getting it done" phase. Nobody has given any thought (any REAL thought) to the costs vs. benefits of this war. Cleanup?? Reconstruction? Policing and new Iraqi defense? Cost to US taxpayers with the domestic economic situation very shaky? Humanitarian needs?? Not many super-patriotic zealots would care to see it, but many Basrah citizens have reflected that thought they hated Saddam, they at least had electricity, drinkable water, enough food before the US and UK entered. As bad as Saddam was (I think he's hiding personally, not dead)..the ruins and relics of Mesopotamia and Babylon were fairly secure. Iraq had decent infrastructure, modern communications, at least some healthcare provisions. I'm not propping up Saddam..it's just something few have thought about. Who will pay for trying to fix these situations?? A 1 TRILLION (with a 'T') dollar deficit?? A war on Cuba? North Korea?? It will be me. You. Our children. And most likely our grandchildren. The USA is trying to take over the world and spending itself into bankruptcy in the process. Real, ordinary Iraqis are asking themselves now.."While I hated Saddam..is not having food, water, complete lawlessness, any better". Real Americans should ask themselves the same questions. Do a cost/benefit anaylsis. Iraqis have little or no choice in their life..whether under Saddam or under US/UK occupation. We have a choice. Regime change in Washington, Nov 2 2004.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
is not having food, water, complete lawlessness, any better". End Quote
Absolutely! :D Why? Because this is just a natural phase in the order of things that occur after a great liberation. It really beats anything the people had to go through while Saddam was in power. You'd have to really know to understand. No one can explain it satisfactorily, nor will anyone be able to change your mind if you're hell-bent against Bush and see nothing else.
It is important to note that there has been more distribution of water, food and humanitarian aid, in general, since the coalition's been involved. Many people were already without these while Saddam was in power.
Delia and Pablo,
Try not to be so negative! ;) :)
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
... and it's been less than a week since the fall of Baghdad. Anarchy usually follows a regime change. It's way too early to say anything about it yet.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
At the risk of possibly saying something I might regret, I'll be the bigger man.
End Quote
::)
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
...nor will anyone be able to change your mind if you're hell-bent against Bush and see nothing else.
End Quote
Good point, Hair. I see a lot of the same behavior from the left re: Bush that the right is so often accused of exhibiting towards Clinton.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Yes, and wasn't it Republicans who were the most vocal opponents of Clinton's air strikes against Iraq? They kept screaming that it was to distract the country from Monica, kinda the same way the left is saying Bush is doing it to distract us from the rotten economy.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Yes, and wasn't it Republicans who were the most vocal opponents of Clinton's air strikes against Iraq? They kept screaming that it was to distract the country from Monica, kinda the same way the left is saying Bush is doing it to distract us from the rotten economy.
End Quote
Wasn't a whole bunch of screaming I remember, just some thoughtful questions raised by the liberal media mainly because of the ineffectiveness of the strike.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Wasn't a whole bunch of screaming I remember, just some thoughtful questions raised by the liberal media mainly because of the ineffectiveness of the strike.
End Quote
That's because it wasn't a full-blown invasion...
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
First things first:
Mobile Chemical/Biological Labs Found In Iraq
Craaaaaaaaaaazy...even if no weapons were found there, why did they decide to hide these mobile labs in the first place?
Quoting:
Yes, and wasn't it Republicans who were the most vocal opponents of Clinton's air strikes against Iraq? They kept screaming that it was to distract the country from Monica, kinda the same way the left is saying Bush is doing it to distract us from the rotten economy.
End Quote
Quoting:
Wasn't a whole bunch of screaming I remember, just some thoughtful questions raised by the liberal media mainly because of the ineffectiveness of the strike.
End Quote
I think it's kind of silly to blame one party over the other for mudslinging and indiscretions when both parties are equally guilty. It's a part of politics, some things will never change :P
But you gotta admit that it's kinda funny that shortly after the sex scandal exploded, they released "Wag the Dog" and then Bubba ordered the strike on Kosovo ;)
Quoting:
That's because it wasn't a full-blown invasion...
End Quote
Out of curiosity...how many civilians died in Kosovo, and how many died in this current Iraq military action? I'm serious, I don't know. Brownie points to whoever can Google it the fastest.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Out of curiosity...how many civilians died in Kosovo, and how many died in this current Iraq military action? Â I'm serious, I don't know. Â Brownie points to whoever can Google it the fastest.
End Quote
Hahaha. I should throw a strawman on you for trying to pull that one on me. Discussing Kosovo is tantamount to bringing up Zimbabwe. I didn't bring up Kosovo, who brought up Kosovo? Still, let me toss a strawman back to you: Do you mean to tell me that it all depends on the severity of the casualties, not the intentions themselves? Kosovo was carried out by NATO. That was a coalition where everyone, except for Serbia and Russia were against (yeah, even the French were not protesting that one). Don't forget that we fought for the KLA, a renown terrorist group with Islamic ties (howzat for fighting against terrorism?). Google it? Why? I know what happened there in general terms. And it is a two-faced policy to not have done the same thing to some of the worst war criminals in Croatia: Franjo Tudjman comes to mind (That Ustashe-sympathizing sunuvab!tch).
Throughout history, Serbia has always gotten the brunt of everyone's wrath. Google that one and read for yourself.
How do ya like dem apples? :) :D ;D
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Out of curiosity...how many civilians died in Kosovo, and how many died in this current Iraq military action? Â I'm serious, I don't know. Â Brownie points to whoever can Google it the fastest.
End Quote
Corrections!!
Hahaha. I should throw a strawman on you for trying to pull that one on me. Discussing Kosovo is tantamount to bringing up Zimbabwe. I didn't bring up Kosovo, who brought up Kosovo? Still, let me toss a strawman back to you: Do you mean to tell me that it all depends on the severity of the casualties, not the intentions themselves? Kosovo was carried out by NATO. That was a coalition where everyone, except for Serbia and Russia, supported (yeah, even the French were not protesting that one). Don't forget that we fought for the KLA, a renown terrorist group with Islamic ties (howzat for fighting against terrorism?). Google it? Why? I know what happened there in general terms. And it is a two-faced policy to not have done the same thing to some of the worst war criminals in Croatia: Franjo Tudjman comes to mind (That Ustashe-sympathizing sunuvab!tch).
Throughout history, Serbia has always gotten the brunt of everyone's wrath. Google that one and read for yourself.
How do ya like dem apples? :) :D ;D
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Hahaha. I should throw a strawman on you for trying to pull that one on me. Discussing Kosovo is tantamount to bringing up Zimbabwe. I didn't bring up Kosovo, who brought up Kosovo?End Quote
You didn't. I think the other lurker or Race did, but it seemed you followed the line of logic, so I'm just playing through 8)
Oh wait, no, I mis-read ;D My bad.
Quoting: Still, let me toss a strawman back to you: Do you mean to tell me that it all depends on the severity of the casualties, not the intentions themselves? Kosovo was carried out by NATO. That was a coalition where everyone, except for Serbia and Russia were against (yeah, even the French were not protesting that one). Don't forget that we fought for the KLA, a renown terrorist group with Islamic ties (howzat for fighting against terrorism?). Google it? Why? I know what happened there in general terms. And it is a two-faced policy to not have done the same thing to some of the worst war criminals in Croatia: Franjo Tudjman comes to mind (That Ustashe-sympathizing sunuvab!tch).
Throughout history, Serbia has always gotten the brunt of everyone's wrath. Google that one and read for yourself.End Quote
Certain conspiracy theories that I've read suggest that Bubba used the NATO emblem to disguise the fact that it was an American-only strike to save his @$$ ;) But I never buy into conspiracy theories ::) :D
Other readings I've done argue that the Serbs were trying to get rid of said radical Muslims, so this supports what you said, that we were on the radicals' side...hmmm.
Quoting:
How do ya like dem apples? :) :D ;D
End Quote
Touche, pussycat 8) Sorry about that, I misread the other lurker's post. But I guess Bubba's strike against Iraq didn't work, eh?
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
You didn't. Â I think the other lurker or Race did, but it seemed you followed the line of logic, so I'm just playing through 8)
End Quote
Hehe. You brought up Kosovo 8)
Quoting:Certain conspiracy theories that I've read suggest that Bubba used the NATO emblem to disguise the fact that it was an American-only strike to save his @$$ ;) Â But I never buy into conspiracy theories ::) :DEnd Quote
Uh-oh. "Conspiracy theories." Aim a little higher. Right now, you're just making me dance shooting at my feet ;)
Quoting:Other readings I've done argue that the Serbs were trying to get rid of said radical Muslims, so this supports what you said, that we were on the radicals' side...hmmm.End Quote
Just ask the fellas over there in Macedonia what they think of the Albanian terrorists.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Thank you Rice Cube & L'Etranger, that was very entertaining :D
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
First things first:
Mobile Chemical/Biological Labs Found In Iraq
Craaaaaaaaaaazy...even if no weapons were found there, why did they decide to hide these mobile labs in the first place? End Quote
hmmm, that is quite puzzling. You mean to tell me that those prestige UN weapons 'inspectors' missed this too? Surely not. (sarcastic :D)
Quoting:
But you gotta admit that it's kinda funny that shortly after the sex scandal exploded, they released "Wag the Dog" and then Bubba ordered the strike on Kosovo ;)End Quote
yes that was funny, and a good movie too I will say.
Quoting:Out of curiosity...how many civilians died in Kosovo, and how many died in this current Iraq military action? I'm serious, I don't know. Brownie points to whoever can Google it the fastest.
End Quote
it all depends who you want to beleive. Yugoslavia claimed there were between 1,500-5,700 civilian casualties, but NATO only said there were 1,500.
Something else I have always thought was strange is that the Kosovo incident was justified as a "humanitarian aid" action because of the genocide brought on by Melosovic(sp?). But somehow that doesn't apply now when we liberate the Iraqi's from a guy that drops them into a wood-chipper for looking at him wrong, and gasses them by the 1000's. ::)
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Hehe. You brought up Kosovo 8)End Quote
Yup yup...my bad ;D
Quoting:
Uh-oh. "Conspiracy theories." Aim a little higher. Right now, you're just making me dance shooting at my feet ;)End Quote
Dance, monkey, DANCE! :D ;)
Btw, this is what I think of the straw man:
Str
aw Man Burning (modified because it was too #$*$ing big)
(I know it's not really a straw man, but use your imagination) ;)
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Throughout history, Serbia has always gotten the brunt of everyone's wrath. Google that one and read for yourself.
End Quote
That's the Serbian viewpoint, certainly: and they've used it to justify many atrocities they've carried out on their neighbours over the years.
Brings me back to a point I've made many times here: as soon as a group of people start considering themselves as "victims" (e.g. Catholics in Northern Ireland, Protestants in Northern Ireland, Jewish Israelis, Arab Israelis, the US after 9/11 etc ad infinitum) they start shouting about how victimised they are and go on to do something worse to the other side.
Phil
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
That's the Serbian viewpoint, certainly: and they've used it to justify many atrocities they've carried out on their neighbours over the years.
Brings me back to a point I've made many times here: as soon as a group of people start considering themselves as "victims" (e.g. Catholics in Northern Ireland, Protestants in Northern Ireland, Jewish Israelis, Arab Israelis, the US after 9/11 etc ad infinitum) they start shouting about how victimised they are and go on to do something worse to the other side.
Phil
End Quote
Serbian viewpoint? Well, yes, it is. After all, it wasn't Serbia who had the concentration camps during WWII and during the 90s. Nowhere did I imply anything about victim mentality, but we could sit here and talk history if you want (although I'd much rather not since it bores me to no end).
Serbia has gotten the brunt of everyone's wrath throughout history...
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
That's the Serbian viewpoint, certainly: and they've used it to justify many atrocities they've carried out on their neighbours over the years.
Brings me back to a point I've made many times here: as soon as a group of people start considering themselves as "victims" (e.g. Catholics in Northern Ireland, Protestants in Northern Ireland, Jewish Israelis, Arab Israelis, the US after 9/11 etc ad infinitum) they start shouting about how victimised they are and go on to do something worse to the other side.
Phil
End Quote
Considering themselves as victims? ::) I'd consider every one of the groups you mentioned as victimized BIG TIME.......wouldn't you?
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Brings me back to a point I've made many times here: as soon as a group of people start considering themselves as "victims" (e.g. Catholics in Northern Ireland, Protestants in Northern Ireland, Jewish Israelis, Arab Israelis, the US after 9/11 etc ad infinitum) they start shouting about how victimised they are and go on to do something worse to the other side.
End Quote
Philbo, I have to admit I am having a hard time understanding where that statement came from. But I hope for your sake, it wasn't from a personal standpoint, because that is really low. :(
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Considering themselves as victims? ::) I'd consider every one of the groups you mentioned as victimized BIG TIME.......wouldn't you?
End Quote
I think Phil's point was that all these groups (or members thereof) have victimized others equally or to a greater extent.
The real victims are the innocents who do not use their group's previous victimisations as an excuse to victimise others!
IMO Those that use these excuses to perpetrate their own evils are abusing the memory of those that suffered.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
The real victims are the innocents who do not use their group's previous victimisations as an excuse to victimise others!
IMO Those that use these excuses to perpetrate their own evils are abusing the memory of those that suffered.
End Quote
Sure. I mean, when you have a group of terrorists and Neo-Nazis (The Croatian govt.) in your homeland, it pays to just sit back and let them slaughter your people and place them in concentration camps. Excuses, excuses...
IMO, I would kill as many of the enemy as possible because one cannot sit and talk things over with those animals. It's either kill or be killed. It's sad. It's horrible. It's reality. Those evils are the only way to take care of business in some instances.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
I was actually raised all my life to be against war, but lately, after reading so many posts supporting war(on other sites), I'm just not sure what I want anymore, just like so many other things lately... :'(
Maybe we should just take a cue from "Time Squad"(Cartoon Network), and just be The United States of Earth...
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
I was actually raised all my life to be against war, but lately, after reading so many posts supporting war(on other sites), I'm just not sure what I want anymore, just like so many other things lately... :'(
End Quote
Read what is going on, other people's opinion and then listen to that little voice inside of you. Just because everyone seems to be supporting this war (which they are not), does not necessarly mean that it is right. Just listen to what your heart tells you, but keep an open mind to other people's thoughts and opinions.
Cat
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Read what is going on, other people's opinion and then listen to that little voice inside of you. Just because everyone seems to be supporting this war (which they are not), does not necessarly mean that it is right. Just listen to what your heart tells you, but keep an open mind to other people's thoughts and opinions.
Cat
End Quote
You explain it well, Cat. :)
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Considering themselves as victims? ::) I'd consider every one of the groups you mentioned as victimized  BIG TIME.......wouldn't you?
End Quote
But my point is this: having been a victim oneself is no excuse for behaving the same way to someone weaker than you. Taoist seems to have got the point - I mean, it's not exactly rocket science, is it?
Quoting:
Sure. I mean, when you have a group of terrorists and Neo-Nazis (The Croatian govt.) in your homeland, it pays to just sit back and let them slaughter your people and place them in concentration camps. Excuses, excuses...
IMO, I would kill as many of the enemy as possible because one cannot sit and talk things over with those animals. It's either kill or be killed. It's sad. It's horrible. It's reality. Those evils are the only way to take care of business in some instances.
End Quote
Personally, I'd rather live in civilisation: to use your logic, there would only be Serbians, Croats OR Bosnians left in the former Yugoslavia - it would be the strongest left and all the others would have been killed. Any one side of those three have been pretty nasty to the other two at various times over the last three hundred years, depending on who was the strongest.
What you seem to be saying is that because country A has invaded country B, then Country B is within its rights to commit genocide on country A - if you were to think carefully (or even think at all), you might realize that it's a circular argument in that country A can use the same logic post-invasion from country B. All you get is violence begetting more violence on an increasing spiral (very much like what we're seeing in Israel/Palestine at the moment).
Quoting:
Philbo, I have to admit I am having a hard time understanding where that statement came from. Â But I hope for your sake, it wasn't from a personal standpoint, because that is really low. :(
End Quote
er.. why? Because I lumped the post-9/11-USA in there? Look at the entire "War on Terror" rhetoric: "'They' did something nasty to us, so we're going to do something even nastier to them... or to anyone with some kind of vague connection to them... or to anyone who we fancy having a go at and can cast enough mud at" - try telling me the war against Iraq would have happened if the US wasn't telling itself it had been the victim of a terrorist atrocity.
The point is this (and to anyone with the wit to understand it first time round, I apologise for repeating myself again): being a victim in whatever way does not excuse victimisation of others; however, what so frequently happens is that once a person, group or country starts to look at themselves as a victim, they use it as a reason and even an excuse for their own actions.
Phil
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
er.. why? Because I lumped the post-9/11-USA in there? Look at the entire "War on Terror" rhetoric: "'They' did something nasty to us, so we're going to do something even nastier to them... or to anyone with some kind of vague connection to them... or to anyone who we fancy having a go at and can cast enough mud at" - try telling me the war against Iraq would have happened if the US wasn't telling itself it had been the victim of a terrorist atrocity.
The point is this (and to anyone with the wit to understand it first time round, I apologise for repeating myself again): being a victim in whatever way does not excuse victimisation of others; however, what so frequently happens is that once a person, group or country starts to look at themselves as a victim, they use it as a reason and even an excuse for their own actions.
Phil
End Quote
Save for a few overheated imaginations, I don't believe anyone would characterize the Coalition's invasion of Iraq an act of "retribution." We got rid of a neighborhood bully and a global threat with almost surgical precision. Do you have a problem with "de-Nazifying" Iraq?
9-11. Perhaps you should investigate this issue before you comment upon it again. 9-11 changed everything. We did not invade Iraq directly because of it, but we did (finally) take global terrorism seriously.
Subject: Re: Baghdad Fell & The Majority Of Iraqis Are Chee
Quoting:
Save for a few overheated imaginations, I don't believe anyone would characterize the Coalition's invasion of Iraq an act of "retribution." Â We got rid of a neighborhood bully and a global threat with almost surgical precision. Â Do you have a problem with "de-Nazifying" Iraq?
End Quote
You still misunderstand: I didn't say it was "retribution". Saddam a "global threat"? Puh-lease. I am extremely thankful that the execution of this war has been as precise as it has, but that still doesn't make it a justifiable one.
As for "de-nazification" - be as emotive as you like, .
It will be interesting to see whether any democracy in Iraq lasts, given an apparent desire from the majority for an Islamic state...
Quoting:
9-11. Â Perhaps you should investigate this issue before you comment upon it again. Â 9-11 changed everything. Â We did not invade Iraq directly because of it, but we did (finally) take global terrorism seriously. Â
End Quote
You still ain't reading what I've actually said, are you? "9-11 changed everything" - yes, the US became a victim and since then has invaded two countries... Now, it's wrong to generalize about a whole country, but when you look at the rhetoric used by all leading commentators in the run-up to the war in Iraq, 9-11 was never far from their lips.
What I actually said was: "try telling me the war against Iraq would have happened if the US wasn't telling itself it had been the victim of a terrorist atrocity."
Phil